February Meeting Summary
The AZ Trout Unlimited-Public Policy Committee (AZTU-PPC) did not hold its normal meeting on February 8, 2024, but held its Annual Strategic Planning Summit at the Audubon facility on Saturday, February 24, 2024 from 8:00 am to noon.
The AZTU-PPC recognized Tom Osterday for his service and leadership of AZTU-PPC. Tom founded the committee in early 2018 and served as its chair through September 30, 2022. His leadership created the foundation for the ongoing activities of the AZTU-PPC.
The members also broke into two groups, Conservation Policy and Government Affairs, and developed our action plans for the 2023/2024 fiscal year. The key-note speaker was Trent Blomberg, the Council Coordinator/Assistant Legislative Liaison with the Arizona Department of Water Resources. His presentation covered the five recommendations from the Governor's Water Policy Council. Click here for his presentation: Governor's Water Policy Council Report . He spoke about a proposed bill, HB2857, that would establish Rural Groundwater Management Areas, giving local control to groundwater in rural Arizona.This is a bill that we strongly support but, unfortunately, it did not get a hearing in the Natural Resources, Energy & Water Committee. A competing bill, SB1221 would make it more difficult to provide meaningful local management of groundwater. Trent is hopeful that SB1221 might be modified to incorporate some of the components of HB2857. Here is a summary of why we oppose SB1221 as currently written: SB1221 - Why We Oppose. For more on this topic, see the Groundwater News in Arizona section below.
Legislative Update
The state legislature is in full swing.
The good news, I am happy to report that of the bills that we’ve been tracking, three died a quiet death (HB2021, HB2022, HB2376) and didn’t make it to the House Floor. The reason that this happens is never made public but it usually means that the bills did not have enough votes to pass and therefore are left out of a floor vote. With that, I want to give a giant THANK YOU to all of you who contacted your representatives, voiced your opposition to these bills, and helped kill them.
The bad news, one bad public lands bill and five memorials are still alive and well and headed to the Senate. A note on memorials. The five memorials in question here are not actionable items, they are official statements to the White House and to our congressional leaders. I’ll ask you; do you want a fringe group of our state legislators sending a message to the administration that Arizonans don’t value our public lands and would prefer that they be taken away from us? Me neither! Further, with every one of these memorials, a stronger and stronger case for the privatization of our public lands is being made. At this time, the best thing the sporting and outdoor recreation community (that’s you) can do is call your Senator and tell them that, as a sportsman, camper, birder, Arizona public lands owner, … the bills and memorials below are misguided and do not represent you or the rest of Arizona’s outdoor community. It’s so easy and, if you’d rather not call and talk to a live person, you can just call after hours and leave a message.
Don’t know who your Senator is? Find them here: https://www.azleg.gov/findmylegislator/
As these bills progress, I will continue to provide updates on the most effective ways to voice your opposition.
Bills Summary:
HB2377: Primarily Sponsored by AZ Representatives Diaz, Hendrix, and McGarr
This bill mandates that the state auditor general shall conduct and complete a cost study of the annual price to manage all federal land in this state. The study assumes that all federal land (except for lands managed by the Department of Defense or the Bureau of Reclamation) is given to the state at no cost.
HCM2006: Primarily Sponsored by AZ Representative Griffin
Calls for Congress to enact legislation that requires the express authorization of Congress, the state, and each county affected before any additional federal land may be declared in Arizona.
HB2376, HB2377, and HCM2006 ignore the economic benefits of public lands and view them only through the myopic lens of property taxes. Arizona’s public lands support a 12-billion-dollar outdoor recreation economy and provide over 106,000 direct jobs. Scroll down to see examples where small transfers of private land to the Federal Government provided access to tens of thousands of acres of public lands for outdoor recreation.
HCM2005: Primarily Sponsored by AZ Representative Smith
This resolution urges Congress and the President to pass and sign legislation transferring 30% of federally protected public lands to their respective states by 2030.
HCM2005 is a misguided rebuttal to the 30X30 Initiative. The 30X30 initiative is no threat to Arizona’s private land owners and is not an attempt to obtain more federal lands in our state. It’s rather an initiative that aims to conserve 30% of our nation’s wild places. An attempt to transfer 30% of our lands — the same lands that we hunt and fish on — to the state that is mandated to profit from them can only be seen as an outright attack on, and complete disregard for, Arizona’s hunting and angling community.
HCM2007: Primarily Sponsored by AZ Representative Biasiucci
Urges the President to repeal the recent designation of the Grand Canyon Footprints National Monument in Northern Arizona and oppose any such designation in the state of Arizona in the future.
HCM2008: Primarily Sponsored by AZ Representative Gillette
Calls for the Antiquities Act of 1906 to be repealed or amended to reaffirm that entire landscapes, animate life, such as birds and mammals, and common plants and vegetation are not considered “landmarks, structures, or objects” under federal law. In 1950, Congress amended the Antiquities Act to provide an exemption for the state of Wyoming, which requires the “express authorization of Congress” to declare any additional national monuments in that state. HCM 2008 calls on Congress and the President to extend the exemption to all Western States.
HCM2007 and HCM2008 call to repeal the newly designated Grand Canyon Footprints National Monument (which explicitly calls out hunting and angling as activities to be protected) and the Antiquities Act that was used to create it. If these resolutions were to come to fruition, it would leave Arizona’s greatest wilderness and one of the world’s finest mule deer herds without protection from the consequences and habitat fragmentation of uranium mining and energy development like solar and wind farms. Further, repealing the Antiquities Act, which has been used by eighteen past presidents (nine Republicans and nine Democrats) would leave us without a powerful tool in the effort to conserve our wildlife and habitat for future generations
Groundwater News in Arizona
Groundwater regulation is a hot topic in this legislative session. The Ad-hoc Committee in Arizona continues to promote the message that local control of groundwater in rural communities is critical to their livelihoods. Twenty percent of Arizona's groundwater became managed in 1980 with the "Groundwater Management of 1980". But the other 80% of groundwater in Arizona still has no protection. Landowners can pump as much water as they want, without measurement, reporting or limit. The group working with the Arizona Department of Water Resources is looking to find an executable protocol for managing water outside of the Active Management Areas (AMA) of Phoenix, Prescott, Pinal County, Tucson, and Santa Cruz which were established by legislation in 1980. The Douglas AMA was established in 2022. The draft legislation would empower local and rural communities to create Rural Groundwater Management Areas if the groundwater in their rural community became threatened.
Update: The Governor's Water Policy Committee has provided recommendations to the Governor. The key recommendations for Rural Groundwater Management are:
- Allow local communities to take action when the data shows that a basin is being over drafted (more water being taken out than going in)
- In the event that a basin is being over drafted, a Council, made up of local leaders would be formed to ascertain the specific needs of the community and to propose an action plan to address the issues.
- The Arizona Department of Water Resources would provide the science-based data to lead the corrective action.
- The designation of a Rural Groundwater Management Area periodically to determine if the need continued.
You can access the complete Report from the Council at: https://www.azwater.gov/sites/default/files/2024-01/GWPC_Report_2024.pdf
The Committee is currently meeting with legislators, educating them on the challenges and advocating for Rural Groundwater Management Areas legislation.
We encourage you to be alert for calls to support the Rural Groundwater Stewardship Areas legislation in the current legislative session!
Upcoming Public Policy Events
There will be an AZTU-PPC Meeting on Thursday, March 14, 2024. Jim Strogen, a TU member with the Gila Chapter, will be the guest speaker and will provide an update on the Glen Canyon Dam Adaptive Management Program as well as a recent SEIS issued in connection with the smallmouth bass invasion into the Lees Ferry fishery and the impact on the rainbow and brown trout population.
The AZTU-Public Policy Committee hosts a virtual meeting on the second Thursday of the month at 7:00 until 8:00 PM. If you are interested, please contact Ron Stearns at PublicPolicyChair@az-tu.org.
|