Both pharmacists and dermatologists selected the top three brands in each product category assigned to them. A top-ranked brand got 5 points, second place, 3, and third place, 1. Unranked got no points. Brands were ranked by the total number of points received.
No compensation or incentives were given to the participants. The pharmacists and dermatologists did comment on how familiar they were with the categories they were asked to rate, but financial ties to companies were not tracked. No responses mentioned conflicts of interest, according to US News.
The Winners
Among the many products ranked No. 1 in various categories by pharmacists are:
Arthritis creams: Voltaren
Arthritis pain relief: Aleve
Back pain: Motrin
Blood pressure monitors: Omron
Burn treatment: Neosporin
Children’s cough medicine: Children’s Delsym
Children’s multivitamins: Flintstones
Decongestants (Oral): Sudafed (Pseudoephedrine)
Diarrhea remedies: Imodium
Fish oil/omega-3 supplements: Nature Made
Men’s multivitamins: Centrum
Women’s multivitamins: One A Day
Sore throat sprays: Chloraseptic
Among the many products evaluated by dermatologists and ranked No. 1:
Baby sunscreens: Aveeno Baby
Baby wipes: Aveeno
Dandruff shampoos: Head and Shoulders
Diaper rash: Desitin
Eye creams (anti-wrinkle): La Roche-Posay
Face moisturizers: CeraVe
Hand creams: Neutrogena
Moisturizers with SPF, night creams: CeraVe
Sunscreens (Facial): EltaMD
Wrinkle creams: Neutrogena
Perspectives
A pharmacist and two dermatologists reviewed the new report for WebMD and had some additional suggestions on how to use it and what other actions are needed to find effective products.
The experts see a need for guidance.
“The variety of products available for similar indications marketed by different manufacturers can be overwhelming and difficult for consumers to navigate,” said Melody Berg, PharmD, editorial director of patient medication information for ASHP (the American Society of Health-System
Pharmacists). “Although this list attempts to help make that decision more manageable, it cannot replace the medical expertise of a pharmacist or other health care provider.”
Besides encouraging people to speak with their pharmacist, she stressed the importance of knowing what the active ingredient is in a product, not simply the brand name.
Truth About Skin Lotions and Creams
WebMD shares myths and facts about dry skin lotions, creams, soaps, and other remedies.
She suggested using the new report “as a launching point for discussion” with one’s pharmacist. The ASHP patient medication website Safe Medication also provides valid information on OTC products, she said.
When choosing OTC products, individual needs and personal specifics must be considered, said John Barbieri, MD, assistant professor of dermatology at Harvard Medical School and director of the Advanced Acne Therapeutics Clinic at Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston. “When it comes to skin care, it’s important to consider which ingredients and formulations make the most sense for someone’s skin type and skin care goals,” he said.
He also urges people to think about an overall skin care routine, not just to focus on single products.
For skin care products, “I would look for products that are dermatologist-approved or recommended,” said Mamina Turegano, MD, a New Orleans dermatologist. “Oftentimes these are brands that have rigorous research behind the products and their ingredients.”
These products often avoid the use of fragrance and dyes, she said, which are problematic for some.
|