Water Quality Testing Differs Between Chicago and Other U.S. Cities
Chicago Schools Testing Later, Less Often than Others
 
Following the water crisis in Flint, Michigan, people across the nation have started asking more questions about their own water's lead content. To help contextualize the testing procedures in Chicago, we are providing a comparison to two other major U.S. cities: New York and Los Angeles. 

All public water systems are required by the EPA to test water taps in residential homes for lead contamination. A look at the most recent round of testing in America's three most populated cities shows that while all three followed EPA requirements, there are important testing and reporting variations that can affect the quality of drinking water for residents.

Public School Testing
x
Although the EPA requires residential lead testing, there is no federal requirement for testing public schools. A 1996 court case struck down provisions in the federal Safe Water Drinking Act requiring school testing, and left those regulations up to state government. However, school districts in New York and Los Angeles voluntarily tested their own taps years ago.

Los Angeles Unified School District began testing some schools in 1988. The same year, they adopted a mandatory flushing program, requiring water fountains and faucets to run for 30 seconds before use every day. The EPA suggests this basic remedy to reduce the lead contamination that occurs when water sits in pipes overnight. In 2008, the District tested all schools again, and they are currently reviewing those results to continue remediation measures.

New York began testing public schools in 2002. The city completed tests of all schools built before the 1986 national ban on lead plumbing in construction projects. Unlike LA, New York has not tested schools built after 1986. The New York State Assembly passed legislation this year to require regular lead testing in all public schools. The results of past tests are also available online.

Chicago Public Schools began testing water for lead in public schools this year after pressure from the media and concerned parents. Initial test results have found lead levels over the acceptable EPA standard in 75 (or 18%) of the District's 422 elementary schools. According to the Chicago Sun-Times, the District plans to test all remaining schools in the fall.
 ______________________________________________________________

Lead Testing in Public Schools
New York, Chicago, and Los Angeles
x
Compiled by the Illinois Campaign for Political Reform
_____________________________________________________________________

Residential Testing
x
Chicago and Los Angeles both test residential taps for lead every three years, as required by the EPA. New York has exceeded their requirement by testing annually over the past three years. For the most recent reporting three-year period, Chicago has reported 50 lead tap tests to the EPA, the lowest number of the three cities. Los Angeles reported 103 tap tests and New York has reported 761 tap tests during the past three years. 

There is also variation in how testing sites are chosen.  A report from the Chicago Tribune revealed that Chicago's testing sites are often the homes of former Department of Water Management Employees, which limits the areas of the city that are represented in the testing pool. This form of site selection does not violate the EPA standard, however, other cities have chosen their sites differently. For example, Los Angeles invites its residents to apply to become a testing site, which increases the likelihood that those sites are spread across the city.

ICPR Data and Research Analysts Aaron Feldman and Jack Lockhart contributed to this report. 

For more information, attend our upcoming event:

Contact: Sarah Brune at 312-436-1274 or sarah@ilcampaign.org
The Illinois Campaign for Political Reform
312.436.1274
36 W Randolph #405, Chicago
Copyright © 2014. All Rights Reserved.