1. FDA has more than adequate
powers under existing law to ensure food safety and effectively
deal with foodborne illness outbreaks. FDA has
power to inspect, power to detain product and can readily obtain
court orders to seize adulterated or misbranded food products or
enjoin them from being sold. The problem isn't that FDA needs more
power; it's that FDA does not effectively use the power it
currently has.
2. S.510
will give FDA extensive power to regulate food in intrastate
commerce; state and local governments are more than
capable of handling any problems related to food in intrastate
commerce. All the major outbreaks of foodborne illness involve
either imported food or food in interstate commerce.
3. S.510
will hurt our ability as a nation to be self-sufficient in food
production; it has more lenient inspection requirements
for foreign than domestic producers creating an unfair advantage
for food imports. Giving an advantage to foreign producers will
only increase the amount of food imported into this country that
does not meet our domestic standards. S.510 does not address food
security--the ability of a country to produce enough food to meet
its own needs.
4. S.510
will provide a competitive advantage to industrial food
producers--the sector of the food system causing most of
the food safety problems; they will benefit from this legislation
because it will cripple many small farmers and local producers--the
solution to the food safety problems in this country. The bill will
impose burdensome regulations that will punish local food
producers, many of whom won't have the economies of scale to comply
with S.510's requirements.
5. S.510
gives FDA the power to dictate growers' practices by
establishing national standards for produce; the same standards
applying to big firms--where the food safety problems have
occurred--will apply as well to small growers who have had no food
safety issues. Small growers will be forced to change practices
that have produced safe, quality food.
6. S.510
does nothing to address many significant food safety problems in
this country, such as those resulting from confined animal
feeding operations (CAFOs), genetically modified organisms (GMOs),
and various contaminants (e.g., BPA, pesticides, herbicides,
etc.).
7. Food
Safety Plan requirements in S.510 can be used to drive small farms
and local producers out of business. Small producers will
be overwhelmed with extensive paperwork requirements, most of which
have no connection to safe food.