Aligned Grey and White.png


Weekly Update



February 2, 2024

Measure what matters says bill sponsor

This week, the House Committee on Elementary & Secondary Education heard HB 2184 (Haffner), a bill that would modify school accountability metrics for Missouri's public and public charter schools.


The current system, MSIP 6, measures student achievement and growth; however, public schools also receive points for other factors like improvement planning and required documentation. In the current system, achievement and growth comprise about 48% of the available points. Haffner's bill would eliminate all other measures except achievement and growth.

 

"We need to be measuring what matters to student achievement, student growth, college, and career readiness while providing parents more transparency as to how individual schools and school districts are succeeding in providing a quality education," Haffner told the committee.


The bill proposes separate formulas for elementary schools and high schools. Elementary schools would be measured 50% on academic achievement and 50% on year-over-year academic growth.

 

Secondary student achievement would be measured 60% for specified college and career readiness credential metrics and 40% for a combination of student achievement on end-of-course exams and the five-year student graduation rate.

 

Dr. Stacey Preis, testifying for Aligned, told the committee that the bill provides reasonable parameters and high expectations with substantive metrics that reflect goals appropriate to both elementary and secondary schools.

 

"In 2023, the General Assembly appropriated nearly $10 billion to support public schools. Over $4 billion was state general revenue," said Preis. "For that investment, you should be able to know how well schools are serving Missouri's students using common metrics and presented in a clear, concise manner."

 

Several committee members expressed concern that current annual performance report scoring is not rigorous enough and tends to inflate overall scores. The Quality Schools Coalition, Aligned, and parents provided supporting testimony. The Missouri NEA, Missouri Council of School Administrators, and Kansas City Public Schools provided opposing testimony. 

About Aligned


Aligned is the only state-wide non-profit, nonpartisan business group working in Kansas and Missouri on educational issues impacting the full development of our children, from supporting high-quality early learning to solid secondary programs that provide rigorous academic programs and real-world learning opportunities.


Our vision is that our public education systems in Kansas and Missouri have the resources and flexibility to prepare students to pursue the future of their choice.


We are currently focused on education policies that will strengthen early childhood education, teacher recruitment and retention, and school finance reform.


Learn more about our work.

First Lady and Former Senator Jean Carnahan. Photo credit: goodfoodstl.com

Missouri News

Memorial service announced for former Senator Jean Carnahan


This week marked a solemn moment as the state bid farewell to former Missouri First Lady and Senator Jean Carnahan, an advocate for causes ranging from on-site daycare centers to childhood immunization. At the age of 90, Carnahan's legacy extends beyond politics, as she authored seven published books, including the expansive 'If Walls Could Talk,' delving into the history of the state's first families. She also published a popular food blog focused on St. Louis cuisine. A service is scheduled for February 10th.


In the legislative arena, the House achieved a milestone with the passage of HB 1989, sponsored by Rep. Brad Pollitt (R-Sedalia). This bill, which authorizes the enrollment of nonresident pupils in public schools, garnered bipartisan support with a vote of 86-73.


Meanwhile, the Senate faced a tumultuous start to the week, culminating in an all-night session prompted by a Freedom Caucus protest against gubernatorial appointments. Following intense negotiations, senators agreed to advance Initiative Petition (IP) reform early Tuesday. By Thursday the Senate appeared to be operating with a sliver of normalcy - we'll see what next week brings. 


House Committee News


Charter School Expansion


The House Special Committee on Education Reform voted to pass (7-2) HB 1485 (Christ) which would permit the establishment of charter schools in St. Louis County, St. Charles County, and the City of Columbia. 


Funding for Early Childhood Education Programs


The House Committee on Elementary and Secondary Education voted to pass (10-6) HB 1486 (Shields) which would allow districts to receive state aid for Pre-K students (in the year prior to Kindergarten) who qualify for free- and reduced-lunch. Students who are three years old or more than one year prior to kindergarten enrollment eligibility can be counted under existing law.


Personal Finance Curriculum Standards


The House Committee on Elementary & Secondary Education discussed HB 1727 (O'Donnell). The bill mandates the Department of Elementary & Secondary Education to create updated personal finance course standards for high school graduation. It includes a 7-year review by the State Board of Education to keep pace with economic trends. O'Donnell highlighted the need for updates, citing emerging currencies and online scams. The committee also explored options like expanding the course duration or eliminating the ability to test out.


The Missouri Bankers Association and Missouri Mortgage Bankers Association provided supporting testimony. No opposing testimony was presented to the committee. 


Accountability Measures in Schools


The House Committee on Elementary & Secondary Education heard HB 2184 (Haffner) which modifies school accountability metrics to emphasize student growth and achievement for public and public charter schools in the state. See main story above for more details.


Statewide Assessment in Public Schools


The House Committee on Elementary & Secondary Education discussed HB 1851 (Brown), a proposal changing the statewide assessment system. It mandates the State Board to recognize at least two national accrediting agencies for school accreditation. School districts must create a measurement of student achievement focusing on engagement, authentic experiences, and high-quality curriculum. The bill allows local flexibility in addressing yearly student achievement and removes a standardized testing-centric approach, garnering support from committee members.


The Missouri NEA, Missouri Council of School Administrators, Cooperating School Districts of Greater Kansas City, and the Missouri Education Equity Action Coalition provided supporting testimony. No opposing testimony was presented to the committee.


Senate Committee News


There were no education-related hearings in the the Senate this week.


The newly formed Senate Select Committee on Empowering Missouri Parents and Children will meet next week to hear the following bills:


  • SB 1032 (Eslinger) which requires public schools to develop cardiac emergency response plans.
  • SB 1051 (Trent) which allows the enrollment of nonresident students in public school districts.
  • SB 1079 (Cierpiot) which modifies provisions relating to ballot language for certain debt service tax levies.
  • SB 1366 (Trent) which modifies accountability measures for all public elementary and secondary schools.


  

Read the full unabridged legislative report here.


See all tracked legislation here.

Budget News


The full House Budget Committee convened daily this week to receive budget presentations from the various State Departments regarding the FY2024 Supplemental budget and the FY2025 Governor recommendations. At the time of this report, only a handful of the budget books are currently available online, so the committee limited the presentations to those departments and Statewide Officials. 

 

The committee also reviewed the three Capital Improvement bills (HB 17, HB 18, HB 19). Members will review the ARPA Capital Improvement bill (HB 20) later as some information was not yet ready to be presented. 


The Senate Appropriations Committee also convened this week to review the FY2025 MO Department of Higher Education and Workforce Development budget recommendations. We expect that next week, the remaining departments will be presenting their budgets to both the House and Senate Appropriation Committees, which will lead to the House beginning to craft their recommendations.

In other news


Aligned Priority Bills Report for Missouri


Early Childhood Education and Childcare


Free and voluntary Pre-K for all students who qualify for free- and reduced lunch

  • HB 1486 (Shields) - Heard in House committee on Elementary and Secondary Education. Voted Do Pass on 1/31/24. Scheduled for executive session in House - Rules Legislative Oversight on 2/5/24.


  • SB 743 (Arthur) - Referred to Senate Committee on Education and Workforce Development on 1/8/24.


  • SB 871 (Eslinger) - Re-referred to Senate - Select Committee on Empowering Missouri Parents and Children on 2/1/24


Child care tax credit package

  • HB 1488 (Shields) - On House calendar for debate


  • SB742 (Arthur) - Voted and reported Do Pass from Senate Committee on Government Accountability on 1/25/24.


Teacher Recruitment and Retention


Differentiated Pay

  • SB 955 (Eslinger) - referred to Senate - Select Committee on Empowering Parents and Children on 1/25/24.


  • SB 1013 (Arthur) - referred to Senate - Select Committee on Empowering Parents and Children on 1/25/24.


  • SB 1163 (Black) - referred to Senate - Select Committee on Empowering Parents and Children on 1/25/24.


  • HB 1447 (Lewis) - referred to House committee on Elementary and Secondary Education on 1/18/24.


  • HB 1648 (Black) - Voted Do Pass from Government Efficiency and Downsizing on 1/17/94.


School Finance Reform


Alternative Poverty Metric

  • SB 1080 (Arthur) - referred to Senate - Select Committee on Empowering Parents and Children on 1/25/24.


Other education legislation


Open Enrollment

  • HB 1989 (Pollitt) - Third Read and Passed (Y-86 N-73) on 1/31/24. Reported to the Senate and not read. 1/31/24.

Kansas News

Schedule swells as deadline approaches


Lawmakers introduced 112 more bills in week four of the legislative session. Committees typically go into overdrive to meet approaching legislative deadlines, which is evidenced by the more than 65 hearings scheduled for next week.


Monday was the last day for individuals to request bill drafts from the revisor's office, and next Friday is the last day for bill introductions in non-exempt committees. Exempt committees – not subject to legislative deadlines – are House and Senate Federal and State Affairs, Senate Ways and Means, House and Senate Taxation, and House Appropriations.


Non-exempt committees have two more full weeks to complete their work before bills go to the floor and the Turnaround break, which starts on February 23.


Budget Update


Both the House and Senate budget committees passed budgets for smaller, fee-funded agencies with fewer employees and fewer policy issues or programs requiring budget appropriations. 


The House Appropriations and Senate Ways and Means Committees received separate presentations from groups working on the 2026 World Cup effort in Kansas City. "KC2026" is organizing the activities and events on the Kansas side and is looking for state funding between $28 and 32 million. Missouri organizers will ask for $70 million, partly because Arrowhead Stadium will be the venue for the soccer matches. Most of the funding in Kansas will go to transportation costs. Event organizers say they need more public transportation to handle the influx of soccer fans coming to Kansas to watch their teams practice and play in matches at Children's Mercy Stadium. 


Three other Kansas sites will hold training camps: one in Johnson County, one in Lawrence, one in Manhattan, and possibly one or two different sites in Kansas. Local infrastructure improvements, security, and staffing will use the rest of the requested money. 


Organizers say this event could bring in at least $163 million to the Kansas economy, with tens of thousands of tourists worldwide. Legislators are initially interested but would like to see cities use their transient guest and local sales taxes toward the effort. There will indeed be much more discussion on this issue. 


Revenue Report Released


A revenue report released yesterday indicates that Kansas' total tax collections fell 6.5% short of estimates in January after bringing in $928.6 million in monthly revenue.


Collections were $64.1 million below estimates last month or down 11.3% from January 2023. Corporate income tax collections represented the most significant decline for the state, with $89.8 million collected, which was $25.2 million, or 21.9%, below estimates and down 45.9% from January 2023. Individual income taxes came in at $475.9 million in January, which was $19.1 million, or 3.9%, below the same month last year. 


The state received $344.3 million in combined retail sales and compensating use taxes, which is $18.7 million, or 5.1%, below the estimate and down $16.9 million, or 4.7%, from January 2023. Receipts have fallen below estimates each month of the current fiscal year (which began July 1, 2023) except for July and September, with total collection at $5.6 billion through January, which is $114.8 million, or 2%, below estimates.


Kansas Legislature Hears bill to establish an education funding task force


House Bill 2594, discussed at the House Committee on K-12 Education Budget hearing, proposes a new education funding task force, eliminating the Special Education and Related Services Funding Task Force. Concerns have been raised by education officials who argue for the importance of both task forces, citing the specific expertise required for funding special education.


The proposed task force, comprising 11 voting members and nonvoting members, aims to study the current school finance system, academic reporting requirements, and achievement goals. It must submit a report with recommendations on a new school finance formula and special education funding distribution to the Legislature and the governor by January 11, 2027.


During the hearing, neutral parties expressed concerns about the task force's composition and the elimination of the special education task force. Suggestions were made to include individuals with expertise in school finance history. Committee chairwoman Kristey Williams introduced the bill, arguing that consolidating task forces would enhance efficiency in addressing the broader education funding picture, including special education. However, some maintain that maintaining both task forces is crucial due to the complexities of the respective formulas.


Senate bill seeks changes to student enrollment aid calculation


The Kansas Legislature is considering changes to the calculation of K-12 state aid, specifically regarding student enrollment. Senate Bill 386 and House Bill 2485 propose using the greater of the previous year's enrollment or the current year's enrollment, eliminating the use of enrollment counts from two years ago. If any attendance center closed during the previous school year, the bill mandates using the current school year's count.


Last year, Governor Laura Kelly vetoed a similar provision in the K-12 budget bill, citing concerns about potential noncompliance with the Kansas Supreme Court-approved school finance formula and the need for districts experiencing declining enrollment to make sudden funding adjustments.


The Department of Education estimates that 78 school districts would gain about $13.2 million, while 124 districts would lose $12.7 million if these changes are implemented, with 84 districts seeing no change.


Testimonies during the hearing included officials from North Jackson USD 335 and Prairie Hills USD 113, two districts affected by a recent school closure. North Jackson gained 90 students after the closure, leading to a 22% enrollment increase in one year, necessitating significant adjustments.


Prairie Hills officials defended their decision to close a school building and opposed the bill, arguing that it would override local school board decisions and negatively impact USD 113.


While some education advocates supported using current-year enrollment, they opposed other parts of the bill. G.A. Buie from the United School Administrators of Kansas recommended delaying the implementation of provisions until the 2025-26 school year to allow affected districts time to adjust. Angie Stallbaumer from the Kansas Association of School Boards highlighted the potential for repurposing buildings instead of closing them due to declining enrollment.


The timing of bill passage could pose challenges for school districts, especially concerning teacher contracts, as mentioned by Kellen J. Adams, superintendent of Leavenworth USD 453.


The committee's chair and vice-chair expressed their support for the bill, emphasizing the importance of funding based on actual student enrollment and avoiding double payments for students.


Key 2024 Legislative Deadlines


  • February 7 - Last day for individuals to introduce bills 
  • February 9 - Last day for non-exempt committees to introduce bills 
  • February 20 - Last day for committees to meet before Turnaround Day 
  • February 23 - Last day for non-exempt bills in original Chamber (Turnaround Day) 
  • March 22 - Last day for non-exempt committees to meet 
  • March 28 - Last day for non-exempt bills in either Chamber 
  • April 5 - First Adjournment (Drop Dead Day) 
  • April 29 - Veto Session begins


In other news


Sister Berta with children at Operation Breakthrough. Photo credit: The Kansas City Star

"The Mother Teresa of Kansas City" passes

On January 25, Kansas City lost a legend. Sister Berta Sailer, who devoted her life to serving the community's children, passed away at 87. According to the Kansas City Star, former Senator Claire McCaskill called Sailer "The Mother Teresa of Kansas City."


Sister Berta co-founded Operation Breakthrough and devoted her life to children and parents in poverty.


In a beautiful reflection of her life of service, Operation Breakthrough wrote, "A tireless advocate for children in poverty, Sister Berta was the go-to person for three generations of families in the urban core. She stood up for them in court, in Jefferson City and Washington DC. She helped them bury their dead, diaper their babies, and keep going when it seemed like the whole world was against them."


Aligned had the privilege of touring Operation Breakthrough recently to highlight the center's success with its early childhood program and the remarkable outcomes related to Kindergarten readiness.


We encourage you to read our case study and remember that Sister Berta Sailer provided the foundation and guidance for this incredible success.


Rest in peace Sister Berta.

Torree Pederson Signature.png

Torree Pederson

President

Aligned

Torree@WeAreAligned.org

(913) 484-4202

SIgnature_No_Background.png

Linda Rallo

Vice President

Aligned

Linda@WeAreAligned.org

(314) 330-8442

Torree_Pederson_WEB-3 closeup.jpg
Linda_Rallo_Headshot.png
Visit our Website