|
|
|
|
 |
While RESNET's primary industry market is residential new construction energy efficiency, the meeting's content and the organization's future direction hold implications - some good and some bad - for all building performance companies.
As your not-for-profit industry trade association, we have a duty to keep you informed of market issues impacting your business and to let you know when your voice is needed. Now is one of those times.
Below are four key issues from the meeting that we feel are most important to
NCBPA,
SCBPA and
MDBPA member companies and industry stakeholders. As you'll read below, we have strong concerns with RESNET's direction on these issues.
Speak out now by
participating in RESNET's public comment period for the development of their data sharing policy. As written, this policy will cost our industry market share, jobs and revenue for many years to come. Let RESNET know that you oppose it by THIS THURSDAY. Instructions are below.
D. Ryan Miller
Founder & Executive Director
North Carolina Building Performance Association
C: 919-521-3385
O: 919-841-6207
W: www.BuildingNC.org
|
RESNET Sets 2018 Goals, Priorities and Activities
At the Board meeting, RESNET Staff walked through the process they recently undertook to set goals for next year that the Board approved.
You can view them here. A few items are worth noting:
- The first goal seeks to have RESNET and HERS Raters be recognized as the gold standard for "home performance", a term mostly known in our industry for existing homes. As HERS ratings are focused on new home energy efficiency and RESNET has launched a separate Water Efficiency Rating System (WERS), it's worth noting RESNET's use of this term versus "energy efficiency" alone.
- Quality assurance requirements will become more rigorous and more QA will be performed in 2018. The Board approved the hiring of a third QA staffer that will focus on in-field QA of mostly QADs.
- RESNET will focus on growing "business development opportunities" for HERS Raters. I'm glad to see this, but am concerned about RESNET's mission and profit motive in doing so. More information on this below.
- There is no specific mention of efforts to "green" MLS directories by auto-populating HERS ratings and making this type of data available to the real estate and appraisal industry. Much more dialogue on this below, but it's disappointing that the topic most industry professionals (and many builders) see as the most valuable and most needing of RESNET is not on their list of goals or priorities for next year.
|
RESNET is a Nonprofit Standards Organization - Not a Not-For-Profit Membership Association
There's been confusion surrounding RESNET's mission and purpose for years as the organization changes its role to address market needs. During the meeting, Board Members repeatedly referred to RESNET as a standards organization - one that manages the HERS Rating resources and professional certifications. This is a big shift from prior language and is a large step away from how many HERS industry professionals think of the organization.
On RESNET's website, they list their status as a 501-c-3
not-for-profit membership organization. There is no such thing, actually. RESNET is a 501(c)(3)
nonprofit standards organization. The nonprofit vs. not-for-profit designation
is important to the IRS and should be to you, especially now as
industry rating data is growing market value and RESNET is setting a policy that establishes (from their point of view) who owns it, who has access to it and who will receive tens of millions of dollars from selling it.
Also at the meeting, there was ongoing dialogue about the need for a national association to represent the HERS rating industry. We strongly support these efforts and encourage interested parties to contact us to get involved.
|
RESNET's New Appraisal Portal and MLS Work Miss on Strategy and Execution
RESNET staff presented on the organization's new Appraisal Portal that allows Appraisers to search for HERS ratings on a RESNET website and view ratings in a searchable area, similar to comps for sales prices. Appraisers would use this site as they're searching for comp information for homes, leading them to find the HERS rating for the home they are appraising and ratings for others nearby. That sounds great... But... It's not. Here's why:
- Access to the portal is only available to members of the Appraisal Institute and non-members that are Green-certified. That provides access to roughly 20% of U.S. Appraisers.
- For the Appraisers with access, they will have to find the site, login and search out rating information that may or may not be available. Interestingly enough, RESNET touts the benefits of a similar search website for consumers that is publicly available but missing rating data (we've tested it). Appraisers will not, at all, in no way, follow this process. Why should they? They have a fixed price contract with their customer (the lender) and no financial incentive to go out of their way to look up a HERS rating. The better solution is to auto-populate HERS ratings into MLS directories to ensure that all Appraisers and Consumers will see them.
RESNET also spoke to their pilot project in Park City, UT where they are auto-populating a local MLS that uses CoreLogic, the largest MLS system in the country, with HERS ratings. That sounds great, too... But... It's not. Here's why:
- RESNET staff indicated in the meeting that CoreLogic is "60%" of the MLS market, then "60 - 80%" and finally "80%" of the market. It's not. CoreLogic has about 40% of the total MLS market.
- RESNET staff also indicated that there are more than 1,500 MLS directories in the country. Also not true. There are roughly 680.
- The big issue, however, is that at this point in technology, systems integrations and the "Zillowization" of the real estate market, it's shameful that RESNET is just now working on one pilot MLS project in one city. If RESNET were to work with partner organizations on these efforts, together we would be able to "green" the top four MLS directories in the country, effectively "greening" 80% of the U.S. market and ensuring that many more Appraisers, Realtors, Consumers and Lenders have greater visibility of the values that HERS ratings bring.
|
RESNET Distracts from Actual Data Sharing Issue - Public Comments Needed
The greatest issue of concern in all of this is the fact that RESNET has
responded to rumors about the
data sharing policy its Board of Directors has been developing (without industry input thus far, mind you) by distracting interested parties through, I hate to say it, "fake news".
How so?
RESNET's communications about this developing policy address the disallowance of rating companies sharing data with "green building and energy efficiency programs", which is in fact
not an issue at all
in any market that we have been involved in or heard from. We believe that these communications intend to distract from the true issue of the policy, which is disallowing third parties from providing registry data
to MLS directories
.
NCBPA has been working towards "Green MLS" goals for several years now with zero support or participation from RESNET. In no case ever in our work has any party ever stated a concern with "disallowing the reporting of HERS Index Scores to other programs". This use of "programs" does not make any sense at all. Programs already have HERS rating data reported to them to process certifications. The issue is with RESNET's lack of policy approval for rating companies, builders or third parties to send registry data into MLS directories - not programs.
And why is that an issue? Well, there are tens (perhaps hundreds) of millions of dollars bubbling in the real estate market for this type of energy data. Several local MLS directories we've spoken with said that they'd be willing to pay for it. As a 501(c)(3)
nonprofit organization, RESNET should be providing rating data into the public market (with necessary consumer protections) to grow the visibility and value of ratings in the U.S. Doing so will create jobs, profit and opportunity for energy efficient, green and high performance home builders, contractors and rating companies working in both new and existing homes. But, RESNET is acting more like a
for-profit corporation by establishing a policy that prevents third parties from accessing registry data unless the Executive Director exclusively authorizes it.
If RESNET's intentions are in indeed to create greater business opportunities for its member companies, why wouldn't it make the data readily available to 80% or more of the nation's MLS directories? By not doing so, RESNET is suppressing our market and wasting valuable resources that should be used growing the HERS rating industry, not inhibiting it.
A
public comment period is open until
THIS THURSDAY that all industry companies need to respond to.
Prior to the deadline, make your voice heard by telling RESNET that your company, its workers and its clients oppose their efforts to suppress the HERS rating market.
|
Questions? Contact Us by Phone or Email
Visit
www.BuildingsPerform.org to find your state industry association. Staff are available to assist member companies in their HERS rating and building performance work across the southeast.
Contact Ryan Miller directly at
Ryan@BuildingNC.org or 919-521-3385 with questions, comments or concerns on this information.
|
|
|
|
|