The first full-service mortgage risk management firm in the United States.
Pitfalls of Mortgage Comparison Platforms    
November 9, 2023
QUESTION
We are facing a lawsuit and potential administrative action for steering. For several years, we have run a successful website that compares rates for mortgage lenders. When a visitor selects a mortgage lender, we refer them to the lender. We charge the lender for the referral. We believe we act as only an intermediary, passing on the referral. We only get paid for the referral whether or not the lender closes the loan. We provide a disclosure regarding our terms. 

However, a lawyer is starting a lawsuit against us for violating RESPA Section 8. They claim our referrals are illegal. We’ve hired some top lawyers to defend us, but they’re not particularly optimistic about the outcome going in our favor. They say we may be violating RESPA and the CFPB will likely get involved.

We are not the only comparison platform that refers people for a fee. Our attorneys want us to change our website and terms immediately. I am looking for another opinion. I have read your FAQ emails for years and trust you to give me your candid opinion. 

Are payments for referrals from rate comparison websites a violation of RESPA? 

What are the guardrails we need to know to comply with RESPA?
ANSWER
Several years ago, we provided compliance support to an online comparison website. We found RESPA 8 violations, such as compliance concerns involving referrals, and offered guidance to cure the violations proactively. We also asked the client to revise their contracts with the posted lenders. The client refused to follow our advice. 

The lawsuit and the potential for CFPB’s investigation are red flags. It is one thing to be alerted to possible RESPA violations. I do not know how your referral model works for being paid by the lenders with respect to a shopper’s selection.

I begin with an outline of some pitfalls and follow with a few scenarios that lead to RESPA 8 violations involving mortgage comparison platforms. 
Featured Mini-Audit
Tune Up Your Quality Control Function
Jonathan Foxx - Portrait
Jonathan Foxx, Ph.D., MBA
Chairman & Managing Director
Continuous Compliance Support
Compliance Solutions
Originations & Servicing

Free QC Plan
(Details Apply)
Pioneers in the Mini-Audit
AML Compliance
Policies & Procedures
Do you know?

What is the
Quality
Control
Cycle?

*No sign-up fee*
*No set-up fee*
*No training fee*
*No storage fee*

*No additional charge for FNMA QC Collateral Risk Assessment*

Ask Brandy how to get a
free Quality Control Plan!

Contact Brandy George
Executive Director
LCG Quality Control
Completing the overall

Quality Control Cycle

is accomplished within 90 days

from the month of loan closing, and
implements the following activities:

selection, 

review, 

rebuttal,

and

reporting.

You must notify Fannie Mae if QC reviews

are behind by

more than one 30-day cycle.
The most comprehensive mortgage compliance solutions in the United States.
Member of National Organizations
ABA | MBA | NAMB | AARMR | MISMO | ARMCP | ALTA | IIA | ACAMS | IAPP | MERSCORP