National Republican African American Caucus
Blk Olive Branch Logo 4
For Immediate Release                            February 27, 2012

NRAAC Nat'l Chair's News Release
On Reproductive Issues Can Men Withstand the Purity Test?

 

"If these same men cannot pass the "Male Purity Test" with clean hands, certainly they ought not be the lone-rangers at the table making the choices for women. But regardless, women need to be present and involved in the debate at all stages."

 

 

While in Washington, D.C. this week, the National Republican African American Caucus national chair, and Tennessee Congressional candidate, Dr. Jean Howard-Hill says, it is time for Republican women to be heard and for presidential hopefuls and congressional leadership to be sensitive when it comes to the debate on women's reproductive issues.

 

"As a woman you cannot help but stand in total astonishment watching the absence of the voices of women on this issue. It is insulting to see the harsh and even sometimes cavalier attitudes some men have taken."

 

Howard-Hill points out a statement made by Foster Friess that said, "You know, back in my days, they used Bayer Aspirin for contraceptives. The gals put it between their knees and it wasn't that costly."

 

Shocked, but not speechless, Dr. Howard-Hill says this is not an issue which should be taken as a joke. It is about life and having respect for women and the position they are placed in with an unwanted or untimely pregnancy. She also says that regardless of your position on this issue, there should be the recognition this is a serious matter and that women need to be at the table as a part of the discussion.

 

"You cannot exclude the voice of women, while men are leading the way and driving legislation that mandates what we should or should not do with our own bodies. You cannot hold congressional hearings and not have any women present or involved."

 

She points to the photograph taken at the congressional hearing and asked, "What is wrong with this picture?"

 

Congressional Hearing 1 

Photograph: Benjamin J Meyers/Corbis

The photograph shows, from left to right: Catholic bishop of Bridgeport, Rev William E Lori; president of the Lutheran church (Missouri Synod) Rev Matthew C Harrison; Graves professor of moral philosophy at Union University, C Ben Mitchell; associate rabbi at Congregation Kehilath Jeshurun, Rabbi Meir Soloveichik; and chair of the ethics department at Southwestern Baptist theological seminary, Craig Mitchell during Congressional Hearing on birth control.

 

She answers the question with, "I tell you what is wrong with it. It fails to include women! How can you have a debate about a woman's body and there be no women at the table? The House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform cannot be serious in assembling a panel of 'experts' to debate access to birth control without the input of women."

 

She further points out, "Even among those who acted as representatives of their faiths, there were no female clergy! While understanding the need for religious freedom, there is no way to understand why women were not involved - even if we arrived at the same conclusion, women, including female clergy should have been at the table."

 

"This is both insensitive and insulting!" She says. "It is like having a debate about the right to have a vasectomy and only women are allowed input."

 

Concerned that women are being used as pawns within the political landscape, Howard-Hill says, "I hope this is not an issue where women are being used as the pawn in order to gain ground in the repeal efforts of Obamacare. If this is the case, no matter how much the GOP wants this, you cannot sacrifice a woman's health and her rights to contraceptives, just to score politically."

 

Howard-Hill cites to Republican presidential candidates back tracking on where they once stood on the issue of the woman's right to choose and to have access to birth control, as an example of this kind of political pressure.

 

As also a member of the clergy, she says the church also needs to back-up and take on its own bible-based responsibility of teaching and encouraging both men and women not to have sex outside of marriage. She believes this would have a significant impact on unwanted pregnancies.

 

"We wave bibles and flags, and talk a lot about GOD and Country as a party, but the simple solution to almost all abortions is not having sex which results in unwanted and untimely pregnancies. You cannot not have sex and not expect the possibility of this resulting in pregnancy."

 

She also says both males and females are responsible for their actions. But men cannot and should not be allowed to just walk away from unwanted pregnancies, without feeling any sense of responsibility for the unborn child and the part they have played. You cannot place all of the responsibility on the woman - men also need to begin to take responsibility and protect women from situations where pregnancy is forced, untimely or unwanted due to circumstances beyond their control.

 

Howard-Hill points out that also there is a failure to recognize that contraceptives and choice both become necessary factors where you have forced and irresponsible sexual conduct of men in those cases involving rape, molestation, incest, or failure to wear a condom.

 

She also points out that birth control is used by women for reasons other than to prevent pregnancy.

 

According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention over 1.5 million or 14 percent of American women use birth control pills for reasons other than to prevent pregnancy, with only 42 percent using it exclusively as a contraceptive measure. In a survey of 762,000 women who had never been engaged in sexual intercourse, 95 percent of them used oral contraception to reduce cramps, regulate periods, and prevent menstrual-related migraine headaches.

In some cases they are used to control acne and reduce bleeding due to uterine fibroid tumors caused by a condition called endometriosis.

 

"Understanding the health benefits of contraceptives is something that seems to be missing from the debate simply because women are missing!"

 

Howard-Hill says that this is certain to have an impact on the 2012 presidential and congressional elections.

 

"Woman may not be vocal right now, because most of us are still in shock. But we are talking about it and taking mental notes. This coupled with the scandals among some presidential candidates and members of congress as to infidelity are going to have an impact at the polls - I guarantee you it will, because women tend not to forget this kind of infidelity, and for some they will see it as religious hypocrisy."

 

She points out that there seems to be a "holier than thou" position taken on this issue that makes it seem like women are the villains.

 

"By not having women involved in the discussion and at the table, this seems to suggest men are the ones with clean hands and should take control of the woman's right in this debate. But men also need to look at the role they have played in unwanted and untimely pregnancies. In light of this, Howard-Hill issues a challenge to each presidential candidate, male members of Congress, and those men who feel they should control the debate and legislation, to take a litmus "Male Purity Test".

 

She says, "If these same men cannot pass the test with clean hands, certainly they ought not be the lone-rangers at the table making the choices for women. But regardless, women need to be present and involved in the debate at all stages."

 

Howard-Hill says she and other women more specifically would be interested in the answers GOP presidential candidates and male members of Congress who are debating this issue or controlling the debate and legislation, would give to the questions on the Male Purity Test. But the test should be taken by any male who is chiming in on this issue.

 

"This is more like a conscience test for the purpose of self-examination. In giving answers to these questions, perhaps men will understand the gravity of their role and responsibility in preventing unwanted and untimely pregnancies; and in lessening the need for contraceptives for the sole purpose of preventing pregnancy."

 

The test consists of the following questions:

  

1..Are you single and presently a virgin? __Yes   __No

 

2.  Did you have sexual intercourse with a woman prior to getting married? __Yes   __No

 

3.  Have you had a sexual affair while married? __Yes   __No

If so, how many ___

 

4.  Do you have sex for the sole purpose of reproduction? __Yes   __No

 

5.  Do you have sex mainly for self gratification and pleasure? __Yes   __No

 

6.  When engaged in sex, do you consider the possibility of your female partner getting pregnant? __Yes   __No

 

7.  Do you wear a condom to prevent pregnancy? __ Never   __ One time   __ Not often   __ Several times __On a regular basis   __ Always

 

8.  Have you had a vasectomy for the purpose of preventing pregnancy? __Yes   __No

 

9.  Would you have a vasectomy for the purpose of preventing pregnancy? __Yes   __No

 

10. Have you ever had sexual intercourse that has resulted in an unwanted or untimely pregnancy? __Yes   __No

 

11. Have you ever had sexual intercourse that has resulted in the termination of an unwanted or untimely pregnancy? __Yes   __No

 

Howard-Hill concludes, "These questions may be personal, but they also will reveal to men on an individual level, just how important it is for both male and female to assume responsibility and participate in the reproductive debate."

 

 

More information on the NRAAC can be found at:

 

http://nraacaucus.org/National_Republican_African-American_Caucus/Home.html 

 

 

  

  

National Chair
Dr. Jean Howard-Hill
National Republican African American Caucus
chair@nraacaucus.org
423-544-9696 or 423-521-4294