In 2023, Assemblymember Ash Kalra (D-San Jose) along with four other legislators (Assemblymembers Friedman, Lee, and Luz Rivas, and Senator Stern), and supported by Social Compassion in Legislation (SCIL) and Friends of the Earth (FoE), requested an audit regarding information related to California’s state purchasing of products harvested from tropical forests, otherwise referred to as tropical forest-risk commodities, such as rubber, wood, paper, beef, soy, palm oil, coffee, etc. The purpose of the audit was to better understand how and to what extent California's state procurements contribute to tropical deforestation and receive any policy recommendations from the auditor on how the state could better track, reduce, and even eliminate purchases that contribute to deforestation.
The audit followed a multiyear effort by Assemblymember Kalra, SCIL, FoE, and a large coalition of environmental organizations to pass legislation that would ensure California's procurement (2019-AB572, 2020-AB2002, 2021-AB416, 2022-AB1979) does not contribute to tropical deforestation.
We encourage you to read the full audit HERE, but we are including the executive summary below with key findings.
We will be meeting with Assemblymember Kalra, his staff, Friends of the Earth, and other interested stakeholders to more closely analyze the details of the audit and ascertain what, if any, policy actions should be taken in the future.
We thank Grant Parks, the California State Auditor, for his department taking a deep dive on the need for better transparency and enforcement in keeping our state's purchases as ethical and environmentally sustainable as possible. As the 5th largest economy in the world, it is imperative that we use our purchasing power for the greater good and reward good actors vs bad actors in the global marketplace.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Tropical Forest-Risk Commodities
"California does not have specific policy goals directly related to reducing the State’s contribution to tropical deforestation. However, the State actively seeks to address climate change. Studies show that tropical deforestation accounts for an estimated 20 percent of global greenhouse gas emissions, rivaling the emissions for the entire world’s transportation sector. Because of agricultural expansion, certain commodities, such as beef, soy, and palm oil, carry a significant risk of contributing to tropical deforestation. Tropical forest-risk commodities (forest-risk commodities) are raw materials whose production in the tropics may be associated with deforestation. However, the production of these commodities does not always result in tropical deforestation. Nevertheless, when governments purchase goods and services containing these commodities, they risk contributing to climate change."
- The State May Be Inadvertently Contributing to Tropical Deforestation
- The State Could Expand an Existing Program and Policies to Combat Tropical Deforestation
- Significant Weaknesses Hamper the State’s Implementation and Enforcement of the Transparency Act
|