The Claremont Institute

Center for Constitutional Jurisprudence


NEWS ADVISORY

 

As you may recall, our Center for Constitutional Jurisprudence has been representing the National Organization for Marriage in its lawsuit agains
t the IRS for the illegal disclosure of NOM's tax return donor information.  Well, I'm happy to report that we won!  The IRS admitted that NOM's tax return was illegally disclosed by an IRS clerk who failed to redact NOM's donor information, as the law required.   The IRS also agreed to pay NOM's actual damages, with NOM agreeing to settle for $50,000 of the $58,000 in actual damages it had claimed. 

This is an important victory.  Heck, Drudge Report had it on the top of its page for a while today, and the Heritage Foundation's new news outlet, the Daily Signal, featured it as well.  The Washington Examiner also has a nice and lengthy story, and I'll be doing Bill Bennett's radio show in the morning (as well as several others).

There is still more to do, of course.  (Isn't there always?)  For example, we learned during the course of the litigation that the tax return was disclosed to a gay rights activist in Boston by the name of Matthew Meisel, and that Meisel subsequently disclosed the illegally-obtained donor information to NOM's political adversary, the Human Rights Campaign, which posted it on the internet.  We also learned that Meisel claimed to have a "promising conduit" who could obtain the tax return donor information.  That sure sounds like a lot more than an inadvertent mistake, as the IRS has claimed.  But Meisel refused to answer our questions during his deposition, asserting his Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination. 

But here's the thing.  The Government has already announced in congressional testimony that it was not going to bring any prosecutions for the illegal disclosure of NOM's tax returns.  So the Department of Justice could easily grant Meisel immunity, forcing him to answer our questions about his "promising conduit" and help fill in the remaining pieces of this sordid story.  But DOJ refused.  Which certainly raises a red flag that there is still something the IRS wants to hide here.  Maybe there are answers in those missing Lois Lerner IRS emails?

Rest assured, we're going to press ahead until DOJ either prosecutes Meisel for his role in this or grants him immunity so that we can learn whether there is even more to  this story than we've already been able to prove.  In the meantime, join me and fellow CCJ attorney Tom Caso in congratulating NOM on its victory!  And kudos as well to our terrific co-counsel in the case, the ActRight Legal Foundation team of Kaylan Phillips and Noel Johnson, Cleta Mitchell and William Davis from Foley & Lardner, and Jason Torchinsky and Shawn Sheehy from the Virginia-based firm of Holtzman, Vogel and Josefiak, all of whom contributed mightily to the legal effort.
 
Best regards,
Color Signature (jpg)
John Eastman

P.S.  As you know, I try not to overwhelm your inboxes with emails, but you can expect a couple more over the next week as the Supreme Court hands down its major end-of-term decisions.  We're involved in several still to be decided, which means there are important constitutional principles at stake.  So be on the lookout!  And of course, if you are inclined to support our important work defending the Constitution, don't be shy about clicking the button below to make a donation to the Claremont Institute's Center for Constitutional Jurisprudence. 
  donate_now_blue2.gif