BUSINESS TRANSITION & VALUATION REVIEW
 July 18, 2017                     Next Issue: Tuesday, August 1
In this issue: Family Business: Matrimonial Disputes Can Be Disruptive, and six commentaries on news articles relevant to
business transition/valuation.

Family Business: Matrimonial Disputes Can Be Disruptive
     
Ian R. Campbell, Business Transition Counsel Inc.
In This Issue
Synopsis

Matrimonial law can prove to be an important consideration in the context of family business generational business strategizing, transition planning, and execution of both. This where statistics suggest that in Canada, the United Kingdom and the United States about 40% of first marriages end in divorce.

Members of business families are not exempt from divorce laws. While jurisdiction specific, those laws can result in financial equalization payments between divorcing spouses, post-divorce spousal support, and post-divorce child support. Aside from legal fees, divorce typically results in economic dis-synergy. This where the sum of the ongoing costs of two parts is greater than the ongoing costs of one.

For the reasons discussed in this article divorce can impact business family members beyond a family member who divorces. And the ongoing impact can be emotional, financial, and potentially negative to the family business.

Family law: what is it?

Family law broadly means jurisdiction-specific statutes and jurisprudence (Court precedents) that relate to family relationships, rights, duties and finances. It includes the laws and related jurisprudence that affect spouses (or equivalent) and children in the contexts of prenuptial agreements, domestic (marriage) contracts, marriage breakdowns, equalization payments between spouses, spousal support, child custody and child support.

Family law and family business

At a high level, in a monetary context family law generally deals with asset equalization between divorcing spouses, and with .....
Our book 50 Hurdles: Business Transition Simplified gets terrific reviews - read testimonials. Visit 50Hurdles.com now to buy your copy. Read it, and then use it as a reference tool.
News Headlines, Article Links, Curation
 Ian R. Campbell, Business Transition Counsel Inc.

In the past two weeks the following articles relevant to Business Transition and Valuation have been selected from a population of approximately 5,000 articles.

Selected articles and curation comments are organized under the following headings:
Business Transition News, Business Valuation News, Technology News, Economic News, and Financial Markets News.
Please forward to a friend or colleague!

Business Transition News

Exit Planning as a Strategic Business Tool. Reading time 3 minutes. Quick Read Buzz, July 12, 2017.

Comment: At any given point in time business value represents a very important - and measured purely in economic terms the most important - measure of business success. That said, there can be a significant difference - particularly in smaller privately owned businesses - between non-transferable business value that accrues to the owners, and the open market price the business would fetch from an arm's length buyer.

This article raises several issues and ideas that business owners and their advisors ought to think about. These include the author's (Chris Snider) views that:

1.    businesses fall into two categories, being "lifestyle businesses" and "value creator businesses".
2.    that 90% of all businesses are "lifestyle businesses".
3.    that is a "big reason" why "business transition success rates are only in the range of 20%-30%".
4.    business "exit planning should be viewed as a strategic business tool to drive company behavior".
5.    business owners need to complete what Mr. Snider calls an "Attractiveness and Readiness Assessment".
6.    70% of businesses owners who complete such an assessment "change behavior and go forward with value growth actions".

I endorse Mr. Snider's view that exit planning should be viewed as a strategic business tool to drive company behavior. I believe this to be ever more the case in our current economic and business environment. Based on my own experience of almost 50 years I believe comparatively few private company business owners do that but should.

The article includes an interesting case study Mr. Snider uses to emphasize his points. Business owners and advisors likely will be able to take much "food for thought" from the case study.

Mr. Snider recently wrote a book (September 2006) titled Walking to Destiny: 11 Actions an Owner Must Take to Rapidly Grow Value & Unlock Wealth. That book is available from Amazon.com and Amazon.ca (ebook version only). 

*          *          *          *

It's a Sellers' Market for Private Companies. Reading time 3 minutes. Divestopedia, July 5, 2017.

Comment: This Divestopedia article is interesting on two counts. First, it reports one M&A advisors recent experience suggests:

1.    50% of private business sales have been to strategic buyers - see Business Value Differences That Can Lead to Shareholder Disputes.   
2.    33% of private business sales have been to private equity funds.

Note that one person's experience is unlikely to have statistical validity. That said, the article also suggests the authors experience is that 4 of 6 sales were cash deals at valuations between five and seven times EBITDA. A second source is quoted as saying they are seeing "opportunities in the four- to five-times EBITDA range for companies worth between $10 million and $15 million".

I consider primary reliance on EBITDA multiples as a principal valuation metric questionable - see   EBITDA business valuation methodology: How reliable? - but it has been evident for some time that not all do.

The article in its conclusion stresses something I believe business owners ought to put in clear perspective. That is, a business sale process often can take years to prepare for and complete. That raises at least three important things.

1.    Even if the author is correct that "it's a seller's market for private company transactions", what does that really mean for private business owners who have not at this point prepared their business for sale in the context of selling price?
2.   Of the recent transactions the author has been engaged in, how many of those were specifically "prepared for sale", and hence could the prices fetched have been higher had they done that?
3.    Business owners need to position their companies for sale in any event as doing that will give them their greatest business transition flexibility to be able to better chose between open market sale and generational transition.

*          *          *          *

75% of Americans underestimate their retirement savings needs. Reading time 1 minute.   Business Insider, July 11, 2017.

Comment: This article recites what its title says, while providing current estimates of annual average "seniors" spending on clothing, food, housing and transport. It suggests those four things collectively account for about $30,000 in annual spend - although it is not clear whether that is per person or per couple. It may be a mix of both. The article also suggests that a 65 year old U.S. couple will spend about $400,000 of health care during retirement.  

Why report on this article? Because it is relevant to business owners and their advisors located in all developed countries where retiree savings are likely going to need to be supplemented by increased government programs. This seems virtually certain to increase indirect, non-controllable costs for businesses. In the alternative there are going to be a lot of unhappy retirees who are going to see significant reductions in their standards of living. 
Business Valuation News

No business valuation news articles are included in this issue of the Business Transition and Valuation Review.
Technology News

An AI (Artificial Intelligence) researcher explains what scares him the most about robots. Reading time 4 minutes. Business Insider, July 14, 2017.

Comment: In this article, an artificial intelligence (AI) researcher provides a "food for thought" background on the development of AI, and concerns over outcomes. The article in part focuses on possible future "cognitive abilities" of machines. This where (from Wikipedia) "cognition" is "the mental action or process of acquiring knowledge and understanding through thought, experience, and the senses".

In a nutshell, the author expresses the concern that neither AI researchers nor society at large has a clear idea of what they "want AI to do or become" - but that automation does push people out of jobs and is likely to lead to increasing wealth disparity.

As I read this article it is an expression of "fear of the unknown". That makes it a no less interesting read. In the end there can be little doubt that ongoing technology advances will impact many businesses - some positively and likely more businesses negatively. For business owners and their advisors to be forewarned is to be forearmed.     

*          *          *          *

This robot-made pizza in Silicon Valley should terrify Domino's and Pizza Hut. Reading time 3 minutes. Business Insider, June 28, 2017.

Comment: Want to see how a silicon valley start-up has automated the manufacture and improved the delivery of pizza pies. This article shows, in a series of twenty-five pictures, how automated pizza production and delivery works.

Aside from being intriguing, it is a further wake-up call on how potentially disruptive technological advances may prove to be in the context of potential unemployment, economic development, and business going forward.

It is easy to conclude that technological advances are going to be highly disruptive to many businesses. Time - with perhaps a shrinking time horizon - will tell the tale.

Technical advances - including automation and data analysis capability - should rank very high in the context of individual business near- and long-term viability analysis. Technology advances are clear "business owner and advisor beware" markers.
Economic News 

The New Abnormal in Monetary Policy. Reading time 2 minutes. Project Syndicate, July 10, 2017.

Comment: Nouriel Roubini, who predicted the 2008 stock market crash and subsequent "great recession", concludes in this article that "unconventional (central bank) monetary policies, it would seem, are here to stay".

This after he canvasses various 'go forward' alternatives - including (1) further quantitative- or credit-easing policies, (2) negative policy interest rates, and (3) either raising or lowering target inflation rate - available to central banks when "the next recession hits".

This is a good, short read I recommend to all business owners and advisors. 
Financial Markets News

No financial markets news articles are included in this issue of the Business Transition and Valuation Review.
Newsletter Contributors
 
Ian R. Campbell is the principal contributor to this Newsletter. He has given business valuation and transition advice to both public and private company owners for over 40 years. Other contributors are experts in business transition or specific disciplines relevant to business transition and valuation. They take part in Q&A sessions posted on BusinessTransitionSimplified.com.
Newsletter content ('Content') does not constitute individualized business transition, valuation, economic or investment advice. The ideas, views and opinions expressed in the Content are solely those of the authors/contributors. Provided 'as is', Content may change without prior notice, may be incomplete, inexact, incorrect or jurisdictionally specific. It is used at the reader's own risk.