nhsManagers.net
21st March 2013 

Live Health News  |  Weather  |  Archive

 Preview - click here to visit a Beta version of our new web-site.  Register, now, free for more content, information, reviews and opinion.  Give us your ideas on what you'd like to see. 

It'll find you        
News and Comment from Roy Lilley
I once ran a sales team. A gang of money hungry, high performing, bright, cynical, competitive men. How to motivate them?

 

You can't buy them anything; they've already got it. You can't take them anywhere; they've been.

 

I looked at the data; they were making twenty calls to get five appointments to make one sale. A 19:1 shot. The penny-dropped. To get more people saying yes, we had to meet more people saying no. It turns 'motivation' on its head. They thought it was a hoot. Out came the Blue-Tac. A league table appeared on the office wall. No prizes required. Up went call-rates and sales.

 

There was a bonus; they become interested in improving a 19:1 shot to a 12:1. They examined their techniques and polished their skills.

 

Is it right for the NHS? In business we knew failure was part of success. The NHS has an urgent need to find its failures. It has just launched another review of complaints procedures. Good luck. More post-Francis window dressing? And, whistle-blowing stories keep rolling in. 

 

Complaints?  Six magic steps; Listen, sympathise, don't justify, make notes, agree a course of action, follow thro, review. (Interesting approaches here).

 

The cards are stacked against identifying failure. Staff dare not; they have no faith in the whistle-blowing procedures. Why should they? They've seen colleagues gagged and sacked. They have no faith senior managers will back them. Why should they?  Senior managers get gagged and sacked.  Maybe that's why patient safety incidents are up?

 

Older patients don't complain they are terrified they'll get victimised. The rest write letters; get ground-down in the system and run out of printer ink. The press aren't interested; complaints are invariably complicated and unless they involve something lurid like 'drinking water from flower vases', they seldom bother.

 

Good private companies treat complaints differently. 'They are the diamonds beneath the soles of your feet', one super-boss told me. Why? "Because, if a customer complains and you don't fix it - you lose the customer and run the risk of losing the 15 people that customer will tell. Fix it, love bomb the customer and they will tell 15 what a good company you are."

 

In the best of well-run organisations things can go wrong, it is a measure of the company how fast it finds out, puts it right and makes sure it can't happen again.

 

There's a myth doing the rounds; we can learn zero-failure-tolerance from the airlines. Wrong. Airlines work on the basis the captain and crew want to get home in one piece. Hence they watch each other like hawks. If a surgeon screws up or a nurse is careless; everyone still goes home.

 

The NHS is a unique environment; customers can't take their business elsewhere and we all get to go home.

 

The answer? Three words. Become 'Infatuated by Failure'. A day without a failure is a day we just weren't watching closely enough.

 

We have to be in-love with failure, rejoice in finding it, infatuated by it, become entwined in it and need it like a drug. Hunt-down failure and make the ones doing it, heroes.

 

Forget quality and the good stuff. There is time enough for that; anyway it's what is supposed to happen.

  • If you're the boss; ask everyone to text you something that went wrong today and how you can fix it for tomorrow.
  • If you are the boss's boss; insist they hunt down one quality failure a week, sort it and celebrate.
  • If you are the Boss of the bosses talk to five new people a week and ask; what went wrong yesterday?
  • If you are the Board insist on knowing why complaints can't be fixed inside 3 weeks.
  • Have a Find-it-and-Fix-it day once a month.
  • Redefine accountability; make the Nurse Director responsible for nursing complaints and the Med' Director responsible for the Docs. The operations director for everything else, then close the complaints department.  Hold their feet to the fire. 
  • Do 1 in 3, random, exit interviews and quiz them on failure, quality and near misses.
  • When someone joins, ask them; what's the worst thing they've seen and how will they stop it happening here.

There is no shame in failure, only the shame of not knowing. There is no disgrace in failure only the disgrace of being caught hiding it. There is no ignominy in failure only being stupid enough not to fix it.

 

Failure; learn to love finding it or hate it when it finds you.

--------------------------

 Feel like having a rant?

Please be my guest!  Use this e-address

roy.lilley@nhsmanagers.net 

Know something we don't - email me in confidence.

Leaving the NHS, changing jobs - you don't have to say goodbye to us! You can update your Email Address from the link you'll find right at the bottom of the page, and we'll keep mailing.

MaM Logo
Medicine for Managers
2012 compendium here
-------------
Dr Paul Lambden
Whiplash
Fact of Fiction?

----------------
hero
Vote for your NHS hero here.
Make sure it is Garry Walker Whistle-Blower.
----------------------
  News and Stuff
News boy
----------------
-----------------------
>>  Competition - the NHS MUST hold competitions for all services; this is an opinion from a QC.  It is long but have a look, read the first 2 pages, download it and catch-up on the rest later.  It is very, very important
.... Now contrast that with this from the HSJ; Carbuncle's Policy Director with 5 key points that, taken against the legal opinion, are quite simply ultra-vires at best and probably illegal?  Someone has to get a grip of this or the CCGs will spend all of their money and time in court. 
>>  Big-Beast - more grief; this is becoming routine.
>>  Petition for minimum nursing staff levels - I wonder why everyone is so reluctant to do the obvious?
>>  The Carbuncle - if you are going to work fo them this is the induction pack.  The mission stuff is verbose and up-itself but the rest of it is very good. 
---------------
Gossip
shh
This is what I'm hearing;
if you know different,
tell me here
>>  I am getting consisted reports (from all over England) about the new 111 service not being ready, screwed-up, unresponsive or wrong.  Here's just one example.  I get the strong feeling the wheels are coming off this.  Who is in-charge of this, nationally?  Anyone know?  Good background article from HSJ here.
>>  Comms Boss at Carbuncle quits - another one bites the dust. Here.  
>>  Number 10, Cameron's health advisor has left to join the Carbuncle - there goes any idea that they are independent.
-----------------
Today's Larf
cartoon martin  
With Martin Shovel