One of the IDEA statute’s fundamental “due process” protections is the right to file for an impartial hearing presided over by independent, specially trained impartial hearing officers who do not have an impermissible conflict of interest. This procedural safeguard is why hearing officers typically make a statement on the hearing record at the beginning of the case that they are not employees of the New York City Department of Education.
Earlier this month, the Mayor’s office and others executed a written plan laying the groundwork for a wholesale transfer of New York City’s entire impartial hearing system to New York City’s Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings (“OATH”). This plan would require all hearing officers to be employees of OATH. After the OATH plan was disclosed, Mayerson & Associates assumed a lead role to challenge the plan in federal court as contrary to federal and state law, as well as a move to strip hearing officers of their independence and impartiality.
On Friday, December 24, 2021, a group of impartial hearing officers filed an Article 78 proceeding in the Albany County Supreme Court to challenge the OATH plan as being contrary to federal and state law.
On Monday, December 27, 2021, the Mayor signed an Executive Order purporting to transfer New York City’s impartial hearing system to OATH. On Wednesday, December 29, just two days later, Gary Mayerson and attorneys Elisa Hyman and Jesse Cutler filed a federal challenge to the OATH plan and the Mayor’s Executive Order. The federal action seeks injunctive relief that, if granted, would halt any further implementation of the OATH plan.
We will keep everyone posted as to further developments in this important matter.