Forward View
The New Historians
I grew up reading a lot of classic sci-fi such as Isaac Asimov's Foundation series, in which an intrepid group of psychohistorians attempt to change history through the application of history, sociology, and statistics. The basic idea was that you couldn't foresee the actions of any individual, but it might be possible to make general predictions about large populations.

Asimov was likely inspired by a number of real-life "big picture" historians who wrote sweeping narratives about past civilizations. H.G. Wells, Will and Ariel Durant, and Arnold Toynbee are great examples.

Fast-forward forty years... I can't stop reading macro perspectives.

Here are a few of my recent favorites:

Ray Dalio

Dalio argues that the world is at a critical turning point, and that we are entering a new era of geopolitical tensions and economic upheaval. He chronicles the rise and fall of empires using The Big Cycle:
The Rise
The rise is the prosperous period of building that comes after a new order. It is when the country is fundamentally strong because there are a) low levels of indebtedness, b) relatively small wealth, values, and political gaps between people, c) people working effectively together to produce prosperity, d) good education and infrastructure, e) strong and capable leadership, and f) a peaceful world order that is guided by one or more dominant world powers, which leads to...

The Top
This period is characterized by excesses in the form of a) high levels of indebtedness, b) large wealth and political gaps, c) declining education and infrastructure, d) conflicts between different class of people within countries, and e) struggles between countries as overextended empires by emerging rivals, which leads to...

The Decline
This is the painful period of fighting and restructuring that leads to create conflicts and great changes to the establishment by new internal and external orders. It sets the stage for the next new order and a new period of prosperous building.
Dalio is concerned that China is on the verge of surpassing the United States as the world's dominant superpower. This shift in power will have profound implications for the global economy. He also explores the various challenges that the United States faces, including rising debt levels, political polarization, and declining economic competitiveness.

Peter Zeihan

Zeihan views the world through two different lenses, the first is demographics (the age distribution of a society's population) and geopolitics (the influence of geography on politics).

Following a long withdrawal of American leadership from the global stage, Zeihan believes that we are entering into a multi-polar world. Globalization (along with inexpensive imports) is fading and will be replaced by more resilient (but less efficient) networks of regional trading partners.

Europe is aging rapidly. China is doubly challenged by tight geographic boundaries along with collapsing demographics. America is blessed with a "geography of success" -- access to abundant natural resources to the North (Canada) and youthful pool of labor to the South (Mexico). It is also a superpower with energy independence... at least for the next few years.

In a contracting world with higher resource costs, Zeihan expects a rise of global disorder and social unrest. But on a relative basis, he also expects the U.S. (along with Argentina and maybe Southeast Asia) to become havens of continued prosperity.

Balaji Srinivasan

While Dalio and Zeihan map the rise and fall of nations, Srinivasan is looking ahead to a time when countries are no longer relevant.

According to Srinivasan, the nation-state model is ill-suited to the challenges of the 21st century. Centralized bureaucracies are unable to manage the world's complexity and adapt to changing technology. Globalization also makes it difficult for nation-states to control their borders and regulate their economies.

Srinivasan proposes a form of governance based on internet principles...

...unlike an ideologically disaligned and geographically centralized legacy state, which packs millions of disputants in one place, a network state is ideologically aligned but geographically decentralized.

A network state is a social network with a moral innovation, a sense of national consciousness, a recognized founder, a capacity for collective action, an in-person level of civility, an integrated cryptocurrency, a consensual government limited by a social smart contract, an archipelago of crowdfunded physical territories, a virtual capital, and an on-chain census that proves a large enough population, income, and real-estate footprint to attain a measure of diplomatic recognition.

There is much to consider here... the big concept is that many government functions could be distributed and subscribed to on a voluntary basis. The underlying structure for governance would be supported by blockchain technology. In this scenario, cryptocurrency is a Trojan horse for something much more significant.

Dalio, Zeihan, and Srinivasan provide three very different visions of the emerging world. An easy way to compare them would be categorize them in the four Scenario Archetypes as originally outlined by Jim Dator at the Hawaii Research Center for Futures Studies.
Collapse (Dalio)
System falls apart under the weight of failure.

Growth (Wall Street consensus)
"Business as usual."

Discipline (Zeihan)
System finds a new equilibrium with constrained resources.

Transformation (Srinivasan)
A new system with a new set of rules.

It is possible that we are all wired to expect the worst. Spotting a lion in the grass is a basic survival skill and gets our attention. Maybe this why we see so many images of Collapse in pop culture and fewer images of Transformation. Discipline involves lot of hard choices and gets the least discussion of all the archetypes.

While the future isn't predetermined, it isn't completely unknowable either. By following the news and the numbers, we can be better prepared for any of these emerging worlds.

In next month's article, I'll share a few reasons for optimism.

Jim Lee, CFA, CMT, CFP
Founder, StratFI

(BTW, the Foundation series on Apple TV is a must watch!)
Disclosure: Information contained herein is for educational purposes only and is not to be considered a recommendation to buy or sell any security or investment advice. Securities listed herein are for illustrative purposes only and are not to be considered a recommendation. The author may personally hold positions in securities mentioned.

Copyright © 2023. All Rights Reserved. Visit us at www.stratfi.com