We're talking about Airbnb here, and HomeAway. We're talking about the private property rights of homeowners to rent out their spare rooms for tourists who use those apps to make reservations and visit the Sunshine State.
Bills introduced in the House and Senate (HB 773 and SB 1400) would provide uniform and, we think, reasonable regulation to assure that such rentals are safe, properly taxed and uniform statewide. You've probably seen TV spots featuring a friendly Destin couple talking about how they were harassed by local government when they tried to make some extra income by renting their home.
We've seen this Luddite argument before, as technology disrupts traditional business models.
When Uber and Lyft came along, the existing cab companies did not exactly welcome the competition. They went to city and county commissions to get restrictive licensing and operating ordinances for the newbies on the block.
And you can't blame them. They had spent years, and lots of money, getting the system the way they liked it - limiting competition - and local governments were rightly wary of new, untested businesses coming to their towns.
If local vacation rental rules were aimed solely at protecting the public, we'd say go for it. But we suspect high application fees - not for a vacation rental license, just to apply for one - and burdensome inspection rules are intended to keep homeowners out of the business, not to protect Florida vacationers.
A Miami Beach provision for fines of $20,000 a day, for instance, is not meant to deter fly-by-night operators from booking guests. It's meant to protect the regular hotels down there from this new form of competition.
City officials and lobbyists for hotel and resort companies warn that, without tight regulation, quiet neighborhoods would be destroyed by spring break crowds. But neighbors can call the cops. City and county law enforcement can police loud parties, parking all over the neighborhood and trash left behind.
"Vacation rentals reflect both an industry and a travel experience that has existed in Florida for decades, long before popular online platforms such as Airbnb and HomeAway even existed," said Rep. Mike LaRosa, R-St. Cloud, sponsor of the House bill. "Vacation rentals give property owners a chance to earn additional income, while driving tourists to local businesses in the community."