Weekly update from the National Housing Conference

In this issue


September 17, 2023

Issue 92-32


· FHFA slows credit score transition

· House Financial Services Committee hearing on Basel III 

· Senate Banking Committee discusses innovation in housing supply

· FHFA seeking membership for Affordable, Equitable, and Sustainable Housing committee

· Fed swears in new Board of Governors members, including first Latina

· Ginnie Mae launches new Social Bond Enhancements

· HUD and USDA allocate $1.18 billion in energy efficiency and climate resilience funds

· HUD announces $19 million in funding awards



Chart of the week: Lack of available homes within budget stops 34% of buyers from purchasing

Collective Voices


By Elisabeth Coats, Hyepin Im, and Sara Rodriguez - Co-chairs, NHC's Racial Equity Working Group


They say three is a crowd. And we’re here to be heard. In the ongoing struggle for racial equity and justice, one of the most impactful phenomena is the collective voice of individuals and communities across different backgrounds coming together to effect change.


We – Elisabeth Coats, Director of Homeownership Alliance at the National Community Stabilization Trust, Hyepin Im, President and CEO at Faith and Community Empowerment, and Sara Rodriguez, CEO at Titan Title – join together to lead the National Housing Conference's Racial Equity Working Group. Launched in August 2023, the working group priorities are centered around improving racial equity and justice with a particular focus on housing for Black Americans, Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders, Latino Americans, and Native American national origins. These priorities can be summarized as follows:


1) Data Collection and Analysis. The group aims to gather and analyze data to inform comprehensive community-driven policy strategies. This includes assessing the state of homeownership across communities of color, examining access to credit and financial institutions among these communities, barriers of homeownership, and breaking down demographic data to understand homeownership rates among different nationalities.

 

2) Tracking Legislation and Initiatives. The group is committed to tracking various policies and initiatives that impact racial equity in housing. This includes monitoring legislation such as the Neighborhood Homes Investment Act, Affordable Housing Credit Improvement Act, annual appropriations legislation, and others.


The group will also highlight other issue areas and initiatives, including Special Purpose Credit Programs, racial equity initiatives, community benefits agreements, climate impact, technology and innovation, health, and community development.


3) Improving Existing Programs. The working group is attentive to funding opportunities, comment opportunities, and government rulings related to housing equity, including Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing, Equitable Housing Financing Plans, and Mortgage Capital Requirements.

 

4) Building Solidarity and Allyship. The group is committed to fostering relationships and allyship across diverse communities of color. They aim to invite leaders to share findings, lead discussions, and inspire collective action to advance racial equity and justice in housing. 


In our history and our lived experience, we find common ground in some respects and embrace our distinctiveness in others, yet our commitment remains unwavering as we come together. The Racial Equity Working Group is dedicated to taking concrete steps to address racial disparities in housing and create more equitable and just opportunities for all. We would like to express our gratitude to those who have already participated and encourage others to support the work of the Racial Equity Working Group by joining us on the first Wednesday of every month from 2:30-3:30 pm ET.


For more information, please contact Erika Ramirez, Senior Policy Associate at erika.ramirez@nhc.org

News from Washington | By Brittany Webb

FHFA slows credit score transition

 

The Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) announced that it expects to delay its initial timeline for implementing changes to credit requirements used by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac (the Enterprises) and will provide additional opportunities for public feedback on the transition. The newly planned engagements will include stakeholder forums and listening sessions to identify opportunities and challenges for successfully implementing the new modeling requirements. The planned transition would modernize credit score models and credit reporting requirements in two ways: first, through the adoption of credit score models FICO 10T and VantageScore 4.0; second, through the transition from a tri-merge requirement that necessitates credit reports from all three nationwide consumer reporting agencies to a bi-merge requirement which only requires two. Many housing groups voiced concerns over the initial timeline of changes due to the operational complexities of the transition and the speed at which FHFA intended to implement them.


NHC and other trade groups sent FHFA a letter in June asking them to revisit the implementation timeline of the transition to permit more robust stakeholder feedback. “Overall, we suggest that any timeline of activities be developed subject to stakeholder engagement and be adaptable, ‘soft’ timelines to accommodate future input. FHFA cannot fully anticipate the conclusions and observations that will arise from the stakeholder analysis of the historical data and should not rush to meet a firm deadline at the risk of creating widespread operational challenges,” the letter read. The industry praised FHFA’s new, slower timeline, given the magnitude of the anticipated changes.


“USMI looks forward to participating in the forthcoming forums and listening sessions to collaborate with policymakers and stakeholders to address issues, challenges, and opportunities associated with the implementation of new credit score requirements,” said Seth Appleton, President of U.S. Mortgage Insurers. “As part of the expanded public engagement process, USMI encourages FHFA to direct the GSEs to release loan-level data for Classic FICO, FICO 10T, and VantageScore 4.0 to allow for comprehensive analysis and work toward a smooth transition and achievable timeline that minimizes costs and complexity.”


“This engagement process represents the next logical step in our efforts to ensure robust public input as we work towards implementing the new credit score requirements at the Enterprises,” said FHFA Director Sandra Thompson. “We want to hear from market participants and impacted stakeholders to ensure a smooth transition that minimizes costs and complexity.”

House Financial Services Committee hearing on Basel III


The House Financial Services Committee held a hearing on proposed Basel III standards titled “Implementing Basel III: What’s the Fed’s Endgame?” The hearing discussed the recent interagency notice of proposed rulemaking from the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve, the FDIC, and the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency that would implement Basel III.

 

Bank stress tests, Dodd-Frank, capitalization, and banking system resilience were themes throughout the hearing. Much of the debate centered around capital’s role in recent bank failures and whether proposed capital standards would have prevented the failures. Some discussion focused on how the Basel III proposal would impact the progress made through special purpose credit programs, with concerns over the changes making homeownership less affordable for low- and moderate-income families, particularly people of color. NHC joined a coalition of housing industry and advocacy organizations in urging regulators not to raise capital standards for bank-originated mortgages with down payments below 20% due to setbacks it would cause for increasing Black homeownership.

 

“The cost to consumers is that there will be fewer sources of mortgage financing and that mortgage servicing rights, which this proposal caps at 10% instead of 25%, will go down in value and that affects the price of every loan written regardless of whether it’s made by a bank covered by this proposal or anyone,” said Robert Broeksmit, President and CEO of Mortgage Bankers Association, during the hearing.

 

Other witnesses included Greg Baer, President and CEO of the Bank Policy Institute; Andrew Olmem, Partner at Mayer Brown; and Alexa Philo, Senior Policy Analyst at Americans for Financial Reform. 

FHFA Director Sandra Thompson to address

NHC’s Solutions for Affordable Housing

REGISTER TODAY

Senate Banking Committee discusses innovation in housing supply


The U.S. Senate Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs Subcommittee on Housing, Transportation, and Community Development held a hearing titled “Housing Supply and Innovation.” The hearing emphasized innovative strategies to address the alarming shortage of affordable housing and consequential skyrocketing costs. Dr. Jenny Schuetz, Senior Fellow at Brookings Institution; Janne Flisrand, Co-founder and board member of Neighbors for More Neighbors; Gregory Good, Chief Real Estate Officer and Director of Asset Management at Invest Newark; and Eric Schaefer, Chief Business Development Officer at Fading West Development, testified at the hearing.


Questions during the hearing focused on finding proper technical assistance and capacity building for smaller local governments, the nexus of affordable housing and transit, differences of building codes across states and localities and development slowdowns from design and approval processes, and differences of needs in rural and urban areas when developing new housing. In her testimony, Dr. Schuetz offered several strategies for increasing supply, including reducing regulatory barriers to new development and more strategic support from the federal government for pro-housing innovations. 

FHFA seeking membership for Affordable, Equitable, and Sustainable Housing committee


FHFA announced it is accepting applications for membership on its Federal Advisory Committee on Affordable, Equitable, and Sustainable Housing.​ FHFA is seeking various experts across the industry from a variety of fields to focus on an array of housing topics, including fair lending and fair housing, capital markets, single and multifamily lending, community advocacy, housing credit, and more. The Advisory Committee will inform FHFA of housing needs and regulatory and policy changes needed to ensure reliable liquidity in the housing market. Only completed applications received by 11:59 PM on October 13 will be considered for membership. Interested applicants can apply on the Committee webpage.

Fed swears in new Board of Governors members, including first Latina


The Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System Chair Jerome Powell swore in its new members, including Dr. Adriana Kugler. Dr. Kugler is the Fed’s first Latina governor in the 109-year history of the Board.


“To hear her tell her story is to listen to the American dream come to life,” said Senator and senior member of the Senate Banking Committee Bob Menendez (D-N.J.). “At its core, it’s about changing the face of leadership so that our institutions, these bodies that we entrust with the future wealth and prosperity of our country, can fully reflect the nation that they serve.”


Dr. Philip Jefferson was sworn in as Vice Chair, previously held by Lael Brainard. Dr. Lisa Cook was also sworn in for her second term with the Board.

Ginnie Mae launches new Social Bond Enhancements


Ginnie Mae announced that it now offers a “Social Bond” label for Single-Family Forward Mortgage-Backed Securities (MBS) prospectuses and released the Social Impact and Sustainability Framework to support its mission-oriented work. The prospectus revisions will help increase investor awareness of the value of Ginnie Mae’s securities and highlight aspects of the programs that have a significant social impact by promoting access to financing for historically underserved communities.


“Ginnie Mae has been driving social impact through the capital markets for the past 55 years,” said Ginnie Mae President Alanna McCargo. “Adding a social label alongside the impact framework and data disclosures for our program makes clear the social benefit that is inherent in our mortgage-backed securities and allows investors the choice to identify what they deem to be a meaningful social impact investment.”

HUD and USDA allocate $1.18 billion in energy efficiency and climate resilience funds


HUD and the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) announced new climate funding initiatives as part of the Biden administration’s Justice 40 goals and Investing in America agenda.


HUD announced an $18 million award under the Green and Resilient Retrofit Program (GRRP) for energy efficiency and climate resilience in HUD-Assisted Multifamily Housing programs. Funding will upgrade 28 multifamily properties with more than 3,400 HUD-Assisted Multifamily rental homes for low-income families, seniors, and persons with disabilities. Climate resilient technologies to support energy cost and greenhouse gas emission reductions include wind- and fire-resistant roofing, geothermal energy systems, heat pumps, insulation, air sealing, and more. “GRRP is a significant investment in communities that typically do not receive this type of assistance yet are often the most adversely affected by climate change,” said HUD Assistant Secretary for Housing and Federal Housing Commissioner Julia Gordon.


USDA announced $1 billion in competitive grants to plant and maintain trees, combat extreme heat and climate change, and improve community access to nature. USDA is awarding the funds to 385 grantees through its Urban and Community Forestry Program to support equitable access to trees and nature to cool streets, improve air quality, promote food security, and support public health.


“These investments arrive as cities across the country experience record-breaking heatwaves that have grave impacts on public health, energy consumption, and overall well-being,” said USDA Secretary Tom Vilsack. “We are supporting communities in becoming more resilient to climate change and combatting extreme heat with the cooling effects of increased urban tree canopy, while also supporting employment opportunities and professional training that will strengthen local economies.”

HUD announces $19 million in funding awards


HUD announced several awards to address various housing needs. Fifty-six public housing agencies received $10 million to enhance safety and security at public housing developments. Public housing authorities (PHAs) can use these grants to replace and repair capital equipment or systems, including security systems, fencing, emergency alarm systems, locks, doors, and carbon monoxide detectors. As part of the Foster Youth to Independence Initiative, HUD allocated $800,000 in funding for 18 PHAs. The funds provide housing choice vouchers for youth exiting foster care. In collaboration with public child welfare agencies, PHAs in 12 states will receive the funds for 84 vouchers. Finally, HUD awarded 29 Tribal HUD-Veterans Affairs Supportive Housing awards of $8.6 million to provide rental assistance to Native American veterans experiencing, or at risk of experiencing, homelessness. 

Chart of the week

Lack of available homes within budget stops 34% of buyers from purchasing


The National Association of REALTORS® (NAR) published its 2023 Experiences & Barriers of Prospective Home Buyers member study, finding that 34% of respondents indicated a lack of available homes within their budget as the main reason for not buying a home. Waiting for mortgage rates to drop and for home prices to drop are the second and third most-cited reasons for not buying a home, respectively. The report notes that Morning Consult’s concurrent report across races and ethnicities includes these same top three reasons. The NAR report emphasizes that these reasons are heavily intertwined as a lack of inventory drives up housing prices. 

What we're reading

Amazon announced it’s expanding its multibillion-dollar affordable housing efforts, working with National Housing Trust to foster homeownership for Washington, D.C.-area residents. The company is offering grants to local developers and organizations for strategies to create affordable homeownership opportunities and will then provide loans to those organizations to build or preserve housing.


A blog post from the Bipartisan Policy Center explores a series of case studies on zoning and land use reforms. The case studies include zoning reforms in Grand Rapids, Mich., accessory dwelling units in California, and eliminating parking minimums in Buffalo, N.Y. These case studies key lessons include noting that zoning reform is only part of the equation, zoning reforms unlocking a development pipeline have quicker results, and success requires sustained community engagement.


An article in Bloomberg CityLab discusses how property insurance rates crush affordable housing development. It explains that insurance rates have increased two and threefold over the last five years due to increasingly frequent and worsening natural disasters. In extreme cases, insurers are declining to provide coverage for affordable developments. 

The week ahead

Monday, September 18

MISMO Fall Summit (Mortgage Bankers Association), in person in Arlington, VA

PHADA 2023 Legislative Forum (PHADA), in person in Washington, DC

HIV and Aging Webinar Series: Exploring Data and Engaging in Discussions of HIV, Aging and Housing (HUD Exchange), 12 - 1:30 PM ET

Tenant Talk Live (NLIHC), 6 PM ET


Tuesday, September 19

MISMO Fall Summit (Mortgage Bankers Association), in person in Arlington, VA

NAHB 2023 Fall Leadership Meeting (NAHB), in person in Palm Springs, Calif.

PHADA 2023 Legislative Forum (PHADA), in person in Washington, DC

School of Mortgage Banking I (Mortgage Bankers Association), 10 AM - 7 PM ET, in person in Dallas, TX

School of Mortgage Banking II (Mortgage Bankers Association), 10:30 AM - 7 PM ET, in person in Dallas, TX

School of Multifamily Property Inspections (Mortgage Bankers Association), 1 - 4 PM ET

Introduction to Mortgage Banking (Mortgage Bankers Association), 1:30 - 3 PM ET

MAA Quarterly Webinar Series: Residential Legislative Townhall (Mortgage Bankers Association), 3 - 4 PM ET


Wednesday, September 20

MISMO Fall Summit (Mortgage Bankers Association), in person in Arlington, VA

NAHB 2023 Fall Leadership Meeting (NAHB), in person in Palm Springs, Calif.

School of Mortgage Banking I (Mortgage Bankers Association), 10 AM - 7 PM ET, in person in Dallas, TX

2023 State of Housing in Harris County and Houston (Housing Matters), 10 - 11 AM ET

School of Mortgage Banking II (Mortgage Bankers Association), 10:30 AM - 7 PM ET, in person in Dallas, TX

Capital as Catalyst Along Maryland’s Purple Line: A Collaborative Model for Investing in People and Peace (Enterprise Community Partners), 12:30 - 1:30 PM ET

Public Housing Repositioning: Wednesday Webinar Series: Faircloth-to-RAD Development (HUD Exchange), 1 - 3 PM ET

School of Multifamily Property Inspections (Mortgage Bankers Association), 1 - 4 PM ET

DHRC’s Disaster Recovery Working Group (NLIHC), 2 PM ET

ONAP Environmental Review Webinar Series: Using Tiered Environmental Reviews for HUD Projects (HUD Exchange), 2 - 4 PM ET

Preserving Richmond’s History To Create a Better Future (NextCity), 6 - 7 PM ET, in person in Richmond, VA


Thursday, September 21

MISMO Fall Summit (Mortgage Bankers Association), in person in Arlington, VA

NAHB 2023 Fall Leadership Meeting (NAHB), in person in Palm Springs, Calif.

School of Mortgage Banking I (Mortgage Bankers Association), 10 AM - 7 PM ET, in person in Dallas, TX

School of Mortgage Banking II (Mortgage Bankers Association), 10:30 AM - 7 PM ET, in person in Dallas, TX

MBA Nonprofit Benefits Webinar (Mortgage Bankers Association), 12 - 1 PM ET

School of Multifamily Property Inspections (Mortgage Bankers Association), 1 - 4 PM ET

Housing Updates from Washington (NAHRO), 1:30 PM ET

Introduction to Mortgage Banking (Mortgage Bankers Association), 1:30 - 3 PM ET

MAA Quarterly Webinar Series: Commercial/Multifamily Legislative Townhall, 3 - 4 PM ET

Artificial Intelligence - Promise and Peril for Mortgage Lending Welcome Reception (Mortgage Bankers Association), 5 - 7 PM ET

Emerging Leaders Speaker Series: Navigating Volatile Debt and Equity Markets (NMHC), 6 - 8:30 PM ET, in person in New York, NY

Southland Social (Enterprise Community Partners), 9 PM - 12:30 AM ET, in person in Beverly Hills, CA


Friday, September 22

MISMO Fall Summit (Mortgage Bankers Association), in person in Arlington, VA

Artificial Intelligence - Promise and Peril for Mortgage Lending (Mortgage Bankers Association), 8:30 AM - 3:30 PM ET

School of Mortgage Banking I (Mortgage Bankers Association), 10 AM - 7 PM ET, in person in Dallas, TX

School of Mortgage Banking II (Mortgage Bankers Association), 10:30 AM - 7 PM ET, in person in Dallas, TX

Receiving Community: Building Inclusive Places to Mitigate Climate Gentrification-Driven Displacement (Urban Land Institute), 12 - 1 PM ET

School of Multifamily Property Inspections (Mortgage Bankers Association), 1 - 4 PM ET

Hack-A-House 2023 (Harvard JCHS), 2 PM ET

Imagining Richmond’s Just Future (NextCity), 4:15 - 5:15 PM ET

STAY CONNECTED
Facebook  Twitter  Linkedin  
The National Housing Conference is a diverse continuum of affordable housing stakeholders that convene and collaborate through dialogue, advocacy, research, and education, to develop equitable solutions that serve our common interest.
Defending Our American Home since 1931
Copyright © 2023. All Rights Reserved.