|
|
BUSINESS TRANSITION & VALUATION REVIEW
|
|
August 15, 2017
Next Issue: Tuesday, August 29
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
 |
|
In this issue: Family Business: The Lost Art of Good Chairing, and
eight commentaries on news articles relevant to business transition and valuation.
|
|
Family Business: The Lost Art of Good Chairing
Ian R. Campbell, Business Transition Counsel Inc.
|
|
|
|
Synopsis
Organizing family business and business family meetings is important. That said, there is little point in doing that if the meetings are not effective. That makes understanding the nuances of chairing a meeting particularly important in circumstances where family meetings can be far more "emotion charged", less productive and more disruptive than they ought to be.
Based in Christchurch, New Zealand Kan and Company
offers management advisory services aimed at organic business growth and business growth through acquisition. It just published an article titled The lost art of good chairing: 16 ways to do it better. I asked for and received permission to reproduce the article in this newsletter.
Reproducing an article is not something I have previously done. I suggest all business owners and their advisors read it. It will take less than 4 minutes. Chances are readers will get ideas from this article that could pay major dividends.
Article: The lost art of good chairing: 16 ways to do it better - Kan and Company
Whether its a board meeting, a team meeting or .....
|
Our book 50 Hurdles: Business Transition Simplified gets terrific reviews - read testimonials. Visit 50Hurdles.com now to buy your copy. Read it, and then use it as a reference tool.
|
News Headlines, Article Links, Curation
Ian R. Campbell, Business Transition Counsel Inc.
In the past two weeks the following articles relevant to Business Transition and Valuation have been selected from a population of approximately 5,000 articles.
Selected articles and curation comments are organized under the following headings:
Business Transition News, Business Valuation News, Technology News, Economic News, and Financial Markets News.
|
Please forward to a friend or colleague!
|
Business Transition News
A key skill used in couples counseling can be just as effective in business. Reading time 4 minutes.
Business Insider, August 5, 2017.
Comment: Generational transition of a business - passing family business ownership and management oversight on to one or more subsequent family generations - inevitably results in compromise from arm's length business principles. It also typically involves dealing with, and tolerating, emotional intelligence breaches that would not be tolerated in an arm's length environment.
This article suggests four communication related strategies that may help "tone the volume down" in business family interactions - as the article suggests they do in "couples conflict" situations.
The four are: (1) lighten up the conversation, (2) show empathy when dealing with problems, (3) calm down, don't escalate conflict, and (4) show appreciation over criticism.
It may not be necessary for business owners and their advisors to read this article - but to read it is "chicken soup" where "reading it can't hurt but might help".
* * * *
The Crisis of World Automation. Reading time 4 minutes.
The Market Oracle, August 5, 2017.
Comment: This article focuses on economist Niall Ferguson's recent comments on the circularity of 'ongoing automation potentially creating unemployment', 'resultant reduced consumer spending', and possible (or "likely"?) resultant 'economic rules' changes.
Ferguson is reported as pointing out how this potential problem did not arise when Henry Ford changed productivity by introducing the assembly line to his business. Fergusson says that Ford "redefined classical economics" when he did that - and importantly understood when he did it what he was doing. According to Ferguson, Ford doubled worker wages while decreasing the price of the Model T - where this was not inflationary where production at least doubled. This where Ford understood the importance of consumer purchasing power in circumstances where without consumer "ability and willingness to pay" potential demand is irrelevant.
Fast-forward to today's economic environment where government debt overhangs are huge and getting larger by the day, wealth inequality is a forefront "consumer concern", and ongoing technological advances threaten jobs of (in particular lesser-skilled) workers.
All this dictates business owners pay close attention to economic and business forces that are changing before their very eyes and are beyond their control, the long-term viability of their businesses, and that business owners and their advisors plan for business transitions with a serious sense of immediacy.
* * * *
Why robots will win the coming trade wars. Reading time 2 minutes.
Business Insider, July 31, 2017.
Comment: This U.S. centric article suggests a direct link between increased robotics and nationalized manufacturing. This where the author bases his thesis on an argument that tariff disagreements will result in manufacturers looking to cut costs - and that the easiest way to do that will be to further automate production.
While that thesis is interesting, it is too broad and simplistic. Automation promotes increased up front capital costs, and depending upon the ongoing speed of relevant technological advances possible higher and earlier "replacement capital costs" (or "sustaining capital costs") than have historically been experienced. Other costs, including ongoing labor costs also need to be taken into account.
What the author does not talk about is that automation arguably favors larger businesses over smaller businesses - if for no other reason that all other things equal larger scale equates with "more able to afford".
Something business owners and advisors whose business owners are faced with significant technological advance issues ought to think about as they think about the long-term viability of specific businesses and their business transition plans.
|
|
Business Valuation News
How Your Company Is Valued Depends on the Buyer. Reading time 3 minutes. Divestopedia, August 2, 2017.
Comment: This article suggests there are four identifiable groups of buyers interested in purchasing businesses. These being strategic buyers, sophisticated financial buyers, lifestyle buyers, and industry buyers. He distinguishes "industry buyers" from strategic buyers, saying a "business buyer" is "typically a bottom feeder".
The author also says:
1. "a complete understanding of business valuation would require a college course at the MBA level".
2. for different reasons, those four groups of buyers weight the value results obtained from application of different valuation methodologies differently.
First, in my experience a newly minted MBA may understand the theory and arithmetic underlying - for example - how to develop a weighted average cost of capital, etc. However, irrespective of how bright they are in order to reasonably assess business specific risk book learners need hands on business operating experience to know:
1. the right questions to ask, and
2. how to appropriately weight the answers.
This where a properly developed notional business valuation conclusion is far more than a mechanical exercise.
Accordingly, business owners need to be very careful when engaging valuation advisors to ensure the one(s) they engage understand the business and business risks at an operations level of the business being valued. They also have to clearly understand the difference between a notionally determined standalone business value and an open market price - see
Business Value Differences That Can Lead to Shareholder Disputes.
Second, in my experience the buyers for larger businesses are either strategic purchasers, sophisticated financial buyers, or a combination thereof.
I believe the author is correct in suggesting strategic buyers typically rely on the discounted cash flow valuation methodology. I also believe the best financial buyers also do that. This where I think EBIT and EBITDA multiples are often - and seem increasingly to be - given more credibility than they deserve. This where actual transaction comparability on which those multiples are based is in my experience frequently suspect.
|
|
Technology News
No technology news articles are included in this issue of the Business Transition and Valuation Review.
|
Economic News
Comment: Do you have any doubts as to the importance of China's continued growth to the world economy? Look no further than the chart included in this article - and imagine the contagious economic and financial markets impacts should China demand for the commodities listed in the following paragraph drop significantly.
The chart suggests China accounts for over 50% of world demand for alumina, iron ore, nickel and thermal coal, and for over 40% of coking coal, copper, lead, steel and zinc.
Also see commentary on China's shadow banking growth included in this newsletter.
* * * *
Comment: This article summarizes an article written by Ambrose Evans-Pritchard of The Telegraph. Mr. Evans-Pritchard is someone who appears to do careful research, and who writes thoughtful articles.
Shadow banking is a term used to describe unregulated financial activities among non-bank institutions.
The article includes a chart that suggests shadow banking in China grew steadily from about 40 trillion (with a "t") Chinese yuan in 2011 to about 80 trillion yuan by the end of 2015. It then shows Chinese shadow banking to have skyrocketed to about 260 trillion yuan by the end of 2016, only one year later. At the current U.S.$0.15:1 yuan exchange rate those numbers expressed in trillions of U.S.$ respectively are about U.S.$6 trillion, U.S.$12 trillion, and U.S.$39 trillion.
This article read in isolation might raise a few eyebrows. Read in conjunction with the article on China commodity demand included in this newsletter, one might think both articles together might raise a great many eyebrows.
* * * *
Fresh fears China's debt bubble could burst. Reading time 3 minutes.
The Telegraph, August 5, 2017.
Comment: Ken Rogoff is a Harvard economics professor. He is reported as having recently said China's economic model is unsustainable - and that China's increasing debt and investment driven economic growth will trigger a severe financial shock.
He may or may not prove to be right. That said, this article includes two graphs worth reviewing.
1. The first graph shows (1) financial sector, (2) government, (3) household, and (4) non-financial "cooperates" (presumably "cooperatives") individually and aggregated shows China total debt rising from about 120% of GDP in Q1 1996 to about 290% in Q1 2016 (five quarters ago).
2. The second graph compares credit growth and GDP growth from 2005 to 2015, and as estimated for 2016. It shows the year/year percentage of credit growth exceeding the year/year percentage of GDP growth in every year after 2008.
While this is well outside any business owner's or advisor's ability to control or materially influence it is one more signal that "battening down the business hatches" is unlikely to be a bad idea going forward.
Trump administration cancels hundreds of Obama-era regulations. Reading time 3 minute, thinking time longer.
Washington Post, July 20, 2017.
Comment: This Washington Post article reports that "the White House has frozen or withdrawn hundreds of planned rules, a move aimed at bolstering the economy but that scraps proposed protections for workers and the environment".
This seems to be a clear statement by Mr. Trump the prior administration had no idea what they were doing when they approved said rules, or that times have materially changed. One can only wonder what a detailed analysis of each prior approved regulation now frozen or cancelled would show by way of Democrat/Republican approval.
Consider that the American economy and policies stretch far beyond the U.S. borders.
|
|
Financial Markets News
No financial markets news articles are included in this issue of the Business Transition and Valuation Review.
|
|
Newsletter Contributors
Ian R. Campbell is the principal contributor to this Newsletter. He has given business valuation and transition advice to both public and private company owners for over 40 years. Other contributors are experts in business transition or specific disciplines relevant to business transition and valuation. They take part in Q&A sessions posted on BusinessTransitionSimplified.com.
|
|
Newsletter content ('Content') does not constitute individualized business transition, valuation, economic or investment advice. The ideas, views and opinions expressed in the Content are solely those of the authors/contributors. Provided 'as is', Content may change without prior notice, may be incomplete, inexact, incorrect or jurisdictionally specific. It is used at the reader's own risk.
|
|
|
|
|
Copyright © 2017 Transitus Publishing Inc. All Rights Reserved.
|
|
|
|